The Best Waterproof Setting Products for Locking Your Makeup in Place

Updated 10/09/18
Product Disclosure
Waterproof Setting Spray
MANGO

Some people assume that waterproof makeup is only necessary when heading to the pool or the beach. Those people have never walked four blocks to work in L.A.'s sweltering summer heat with a rising humidity index. I have. In fact, I do so often, which is exactly how I know that waterproof makeup has a role in everyday life. Without it, I'd be crawling into the office with a red, shiny face devoid of makeup because my concealer and mascara would melt off somewhere about two blocks back. That's why, in order to look halfway presentable throughout the summer months, I stock up on all the waterproof basics—including but not limited to mascara, concealer, and lipstick.

But one of the most important products behind a crease-free, smudge-free, and non-melted makeup look has to be setting spray. It keeps the makeup right where it was applied, not smudging down the cheeks or collecting in a dark and streaky mess underneath the eyes. Water-resistant setting sprays work even better (yes, those exist!). Because they're immune to sweat and humidity, they're perfect for people who are prone to melty makeup (like me).

Ben Nye Final Seal Matte Makeup Sealer $17
Shop

This Ben Nye product has received a lot of attention from beauty bloggers since it's one of the few truly water-resistant setting sprays on the market. When it's misted over the skin, it forms a seal that stops sweat and humidity from messing with your makeup (seriously, some people claim it keeps their faces set perfectly for up to eight hours at a time). It's the real deal, though I've heard some reviewers mention that it feels a little heavier and tighter than other setting sprays do. Still, even if the final texture isn't ideal, its insane staying power might make up for it. It may be well worth it for the hottest and most humid of summer days. No melting makeup here.

Look Lock Up Setting Spray
Covergirl Look Lock Up Setting Spray $12
Shop

Ever since Covergirl went through a huge rebrand, we've been loving the chic black-and-white packaging, like that of this setting spray. It's resistant to sweat, humidity, and heat (which is exactly what we need come summer). It's also infused with cucumber and chamomile for a cooling feeling.

Key Ingredients

Chamomile is rich in flavonoids, which act as antioxidants to help protect skin from environmental damage.

Blue Marble Waterproof Setting Spray $45
Shop

Here's another waterproof setting spray that's readily available on Amazon. Even though it forms a barrier between your makeup and sweat, humidity, or moisture, it's alcohol-free and safe for sensitive skin. It can be used every single day, though it's strong enough to work on special-effects makeup (so you know it's the real deal). Take it from the reviews, which are overwhelmingly positive.

Aqua Seal 0.4 oz/ 11 g
Make Up For Ever Aqua Seal $21
Shop

Okay, so this isn't technically a setting spray, but it works to waterproof your makeup all the same. Mix a few drops of this liquid with your powder formula or pencil of choice, and it will instantly become waterproof. How cool is that? You can transform your existing makeup without buying multiple new products.

Illamasqua Sealing Gel $14
Shop

Illamasqua's cult-favorite Sealing Gel works similarly to the aforementioned Make Up For Ever pick. Simply add a drop to any powder formula, and it will transform into a water-resistant paste. Try to apply it quickly (as it dries down rather quickly), and it will stay put all day, despite 90-degree weather with 80% humidity.

Trish Mcevoy Finish Line -
Trish McEvoy Finish Line Shadow Transformer $26
Shop

If it's just your eye makeup that gives you trouble, look no further than this transparent waterproofing product from Trish McEvoy. Add a drop or two into your favorite eye shadow, and it becomes a budge-proof and water-resistant eyeliner. That means you can turn almost any eye shadow into a long-wearing eyeliner. Just think about all the possibilities (and money saved from no longer purchasing multiple liners).

4 Other Setting Sprays We Love

Urban Decay De-Slick Oil-Control Setting Spray $32
Shop

Urban Decay's setting sprays are some of my all-time favorites. Each one is effective and lightweight, though I have a special love for this one. You see, if it's super hot and humid, my skin has a way of overproducing oil so I look slick by lunchtime. This helps to keep my makeup from sliding off while keeping shine at bay. I love a velvet complexion.

Nyx Matte Finish Setting Spray $6
Shop

This Nyx setting spray comes in two different finishes: matte and dewy. Like I said, my combination skin veers on the oily side in the summer, which is why I personally prefer the matte one. However, they seem equally as popular, with positive reviews littering the internet.

Sport Fix Extra Hold Makeup Fixing Spray - Only at ULTA
Makeup Revolution Sport Fix Extra Hold Makeup Fixing Spray $8
Shop

This setting spray is specifically designed to last through a tough workout, so you know it will stay put when it comes in contact with moisture and sweat. Reviewers say it's the perfect pick for hot weather.

Milani Make It Last Setting Spray $9
Shop

Another one of my favorite setting sprays is this one from Milani (which I personally think is a vastly underrated beauty brand). Spritz it on your skin before or after makeup since it doubles as a skin-prepping product. It keeps makeup from budging, creasing, and smudging for up to 16 hours.

Next, check out even more setting sprays we love, based on our specific skin types. 

Related Stories