Wantable vs Stitch Fix: An Overview of What Each Service Does Best

In an ever-growing digital world, online clothes shopping is certainly becoming a popular way of picking stylish outfits. More specifically, clothing subscription boxes take the hassle out of constantly ordering garments, or going to a store and hopelessly searching for clothes you like or are in your size. Clothing subscription boxes are typically issued on a scheduled basis for a fee, which often covers the cost of a stylist who curates a number of pieces for you. 

Of the many clothing subscription options on the market, shoppers typically land on two popular choices: Wantable vs. Stitch Fix. These services are often grouped together due to the pair’s similarities, which include: subscription cost, plan options, clothing brands offered, and members-only discounts. Since the services overlap, it can be difficult to choose between the two. We’re here to clear that up by analyzing what each company does differently so you can determine which subscription is best for your specific needs.

About Wantable

Wantable gives customers a variety of plan options and the ability to build a clothing box with the help of a stylist. You’ll get to pick from one of the company’s four base plans: the Style Edit, Active Edit, Sleep & Body Edit, and Men’s Active Edit, all of which have a $20 styling fee for seven pieces of clothing. Once you decide on a plan, you can take a style quiz that helps build your profile and inform a stylist of your preferences, like size, budget, and even specific pieces you want to try. If you’re looking for a more specific set of garments, Wantable also has themed “Edits” that are curated around seasons, occasions, and more. 

After you receive your pieces—which can take between seven and 14 days to arrive on your doorstep—you’ll have five days to decide what to keep or return. For items you keep, the $20 styling fee will be credited toward your purchase, and you can save an additional 20% if you purchase at least five pieces. Additionally, subscriptions aren’t required to shop for individual pieces on Wantable, so you have the freedom to choose specific items as well. 

Wantable Wantable Subscription $20.00

Shop

About Stitch Fix

Stitch Fix has a large inventory, offering members pieces from over 1,000 brands including Calvin Klein, Free People, Good American, and Kate Spade. Sizes range from XS to 3X, and the $20 plans are available to women, men, and kids. However, Stitch Fix broadens its customer base by offering maternity, plus-size, and big and tall subscription options too. A detailed quiz gathers basic info for your stylist to use when curating your box, like size and body type, as well as style, color, and pattern preferences. Before your five selected pieces are ready to ship, you can preview what your stylist picked to ensure everything is to your liking. 

Once your box arrives, Stitch Fix gives you three days to choose what you want to buy and what you want to send back. Your $20 styling fee is credited toward any pieces you purchase, and if all five items are a hit, you get 25% off the entire box. Scheduling is flexible with the company’s many frequency options, which range from every two to three weeks to every three months. Also note that Stitch Fix doesn’t require a membership, so you can place orders manually as often as you like. 

Stitch Fix Stitch Fix Subscription $20.00

Shop

Wantable vs. Stitch Fix: How Do They Compare?

Wantable

Stitch Fix

How Much Is Wantable vs. Stitch Fix?

Wantable

• Style Edit: 7 items per box; 5-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); $50-$100 per item
• Active Edit: 7 items per box; 5-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); $30-$70 per item
• Sleep and Body Edit: 7 items per box; 5-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); $20-$150 per item
• Men’s Active Edit: 7 items per box; 5-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); $50-$100 per item
  

Stitch Fix

• Stitch Fix Women: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); $25-$500 per item
• Stitch Fix Men: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); $25-$500 per item
• Stitch Fix Kids: 10 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); Items start at $10
• Stitch Fix Plus Size: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases); Items start at $20
• Stitch Fix Maternity: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases)
• Stitch Fix Petite: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases)
• Stitch Fix Big and Tall: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases)
• Stitch Fix Women’s Jeans: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases)
• Stitch Fix Business Casual: 5 items per box; 3-day try-on period $20 styling fee (applied to purchases)

Wantable Customer Reviews

Wantable customers praise the company for its selection of clothing pieces. Moreover, many have commented that the service’s many stylists are not only careful about curating the right box for you, but they are also accommodating to any styling feedback or suggestions you may have. Other users note that setting a budget and exchanging items that don’t fit are other great features of Wantable. 

Most members have rated Wantable positively, but some felt that the company’s lack of mixing and matching “Edit” plans limits the type of clothing boxes you can get each month. Additionally, some customers claim that many of the items are overpriced, but they subsequently commend the company’s return policy for unwanted pieces. 

Stitch Fix Customer Reviews

Stitch Fix customers have noted a variety of pros and cons with the company. Many users applaud Stitch Fix’s stylists, whom many have found to be receptive, creative, and understanding of style preferences and requests. Members also appreciate getting the $20 styling fee credited toward any purchased items, as well as the 25% discount if all five pieces are kept. Lastly, customers commend Stitch Fix’s clothing filter tool, which allows you to narrow down choices based on fabric, pattern, color, etc. 

Though most users give Stitch Fix a positive rating, some customers felt that items were too expensive for their budget and claimed that the pieces were low quality. Additionally, customer service has drawn some criticism from select users who claim that it was either unhelpful or unresponsive to concerns. 

Pros and Cons

Wantable

Pros

• Seven unique pieces included in each box
• Themed “Edits” add variety to clothing choices
• Budget section filters options to your preferred price range 
• Exclusive discounts available if you keep five items
• Can request specific items based on your style

Cons

• Shipping time is between seven and 14 days 
• Cannot preview selections

Stitch Fix

Pros

• Impressive catalog of 1,000+ different brands to shop from
• Fix plans include kid, maternity, plus-size, and big and tall options 
• Flexible subscription and delivery options 
• Can preview your box before it ships 
• Allows you to shop on the site without a subscription 

Cons

• Limited 3-day try-on period
• $20 credit does not roll over 

More Online Styling Services

Clothing subscription boxes differ across multiple companies and include options for varying budgets, specific body types, and garment types, like active wear or lingerie. Along with Wantable and Stitch Fix, here are a few other clothing subscription box services you can try out. 

Armoire

• Base Price: $79
• Free Shipping? Yes
• Size Range: 0-24W

Armoire is a clothing rental service that offers three different plans, with the lowest starting at $79 per month for four items. After completing an online style quiz, you are matched with a stylist that personally selects items for you based on your responses. You always have the freedom to choose what items you get before your box ships and can keep any or all of your pieces for as long as you like. Free shipping, free cleaning, and a complimentary monthly stylist appointment are also included with your Armoire subscription. 

Dailylook

• Base Price: $40
• Free Shipping? Yes
• Size Range: 0-24W, XS-3X

Dailylook is a clothing subscription service that is a great option for those on a budget. The $40 subscription plan gives you seven to 12 items, handpicked by a personal stylist in each box. You can receive deliveries on a monthly, bimonthly, or quarterly basis, and you have a five-day try-on period. After this time frame expires, you can either purchase some of the items from your box at a discount or return them with a prepaid shipping label. 

Dia & Co.

• Base Price: $20
• Free Shipping? Yes
• Size Range: 10-32

Dia & Co. has one of the most body-inclusive clothing subscription boxes on the market, with sizes ranging from 10 to 32. For $20, you can get a monthly box of five garments carefully curated by a stylist based on style quiz answers. Alternatively, you can opt for one of the company’s many one-time seasonal boxes, such as the Spring Essentials or Zodiac Box options. Unlike some competitors, Dia & Co. allows you to view and/or edit the contents of your box before it is shipped and also offers a complimentary try-on extension if you need more than the allotted five days to decide what you want to keep.

Final Thoughts

Wantable and Stitch Fix are both great choices if you want to add some variety to your wardrobe with a clothing subscription service. If you are someone who needs a range of clothing options, Wantable’s many style plans allow you to choose what type of box you want, ranging from activewear to lounge clothes, and even seasonal themes. For those who have trouble shopping for their specific body type, Stitch Fix provides options that are inclusive to just about everyone, including pregnant and plus-sized women, kids, and men of all sizes.

Both services offer similar features, including a $20 styling fee, member discounts, and plan options, which makes them a definite favorite from customers. Since there are several different clothing subscriptions and online stylist options out there, be sure to browse and compare different services that suit your needs.