The One Mistake I Made That Ruined My Spray Tan


Spray tans are one of those beauty treatments that don’t feel necessary until you get your first one. I have really fair skin, and save for a few trips to the tanning bed in high school (I know, shame), I have stayed away from the sun. But I definitely think a bronzey glow suits me. Enter: spray tans.

Prior to my first treatment, I was nervous I’d look more like an Oompa Loompa than a sun-kissed goddess. I told the technician I wanted it to look as natural as possible, and hoped for the best. What happened when I left was nothing short of a miracle. Yes, you look a little greasy in the minutes after exiting the salon. But give it eight hours (and a quick shower) and you’ll be glistening. I looked like I had just gotten back from a quick jaunt to some secluded island. The trick is in the formula, especially with pale girls. It has to make you look glowy, healthy, and awake—not like a different person. (If you’re in NYC, Pink Sands Airbrush Tan & Spa is incredible, or if you can score an appointment with Sophie Evans you’ll look like a celebrity).

Meet the Expert

Sophie Evans is a skin-finishing expert and brand ambassador for St. Tropez. Her A-list clientele includes Margot Robbie, Hugh Jackman, and Kate Moss.

Always Remove Remnants of an Old Spray Tan

Even after years of faux-glow appointments, I still recently managed to make a few cardinal mistakes when I went in for a quick spritz. First, I forgot to remove remnants of an old spray tan beforehand. According to the Pink Sands website, this is the worst thing you can do. My tan was patchy, flaky, and super dark in weird places. The salon suggests, “The best way is to soak in a tub with sea salt and essential oils. Slough off the color as gently as possible. The following day, use a non-abrasive exfoliant.” Evans agrees: “For small areas, use a hair-removal cream like Veet Gel Hair Remover Cream ($8). Apply with a Q-tip precisely onto the areas. For sensitive skin or for your face, cleanse first, lightly exfoliate with a facial scrub, then apply an astringent toner with a cotton ball and sweep over dark areas of self-tanner. Also, chlorine will remove self-tanner so you can always try taking a dip!” She adds, “For the tan to develop, the self-tanning agent known as DHA has a natural chemical reaction with the protein (amino acid) and oxygen on the skin’s surface. If the skin’s pH balance is high, this can result in an unnatural, orange tan. Your pH level is higher on your hands and feet, so it is important to properly moisturize beforehand. Additionally, washing your skin raises your pH, so do not apply immediately after using soap.”

Use the Right Moisturizer Beforehand

Which brings me to my second devastating mistake. I moisturized before the tan, but I applied the wrong product. Additionally, it matters where you apply your moisturizer. Evans says, “Before your appointment, make sure hands, feet, elbows, knees, and any other problem areas are well moisturized. But we never moisturize the whole body, as this will result in a lighter tan. Apply to the palms of your hands; creases in your wrists, elbows, feet; the back of your heels; and any other serious dry areas, like a patch of eczema. The hands and feet may not be dry, but a self-tan can go about seven shades darker in these areas due to the skin being slightly thicker. Your secret weapon when applying self-tan is using moisturizer as a barrier. It’s also important to use moisturizer to blend afterward, around the crease in the wrist, back of the heel, and your hairline to make the tan look natural.”

Picture it like this: Your tan is to watercolor paint what moisturizer is to water—so you’re blending and fading to perfection.

Picture it like this: Your tan is to watercolor paint what moisturizer is to water—so you’re blending and fading to perfection. Now, before every appointment, I reach for an oldie but a goodie: Queen Helene’s Cocoa Butter Hand and Body Lotion ($10).

Be Careful About Which Products You Apply After

Now, what about after the tan? I’ve used so many products that leave my body looking streaky after the fact. And since a bit of the tan washes off with each shower, I find myself showering less than I should be (no, it’s not exactly the most clean quality, but it’s true). After chatting with Evans, I’ve had great success with Mario Badescu’s Summer Shine Body Lotion ($10) as it’s enriched with vitamin A, beeswax, and peanut oil. It shimmers, so it adds even more glow to your limbs and keeps your tan going strong. Not to mention, it absorbs quickly and won’t leave you greasy in the summer heat.

Michela Buttignol/Byrdie

Mario Badescu Summer Shine Body Lotion

Mario Badescu Summer Shine Body Lotion $10.00

For the times when I do have to shower, I’ve become obsessed with St. Tropez Tanning Essentials In Shower Gradual Tan in Medium ($25). It’s a natural-looking, gradual self-tanner that you can apply in the shower. All you have to do is smooth it onto wet skin, let it sit for three minutes, and wash it off. It helps your skin maintain any color that the water would otherwise wash off.

St. Tropez Tanning Essentials In-Shower Gradual Tan in Medium

St. Tropez Tanning Essentials In-Shower Gradual Tan in Medium $25.00

If you’re not into waiting around in the shower, try St. Tropez Tan Enhancing Body Moisturizer ($18) to help prolong your tan an extra three days. Evans recommends, “Just make sure if you're using gradual tanner, you’re also exfoliating every two to three days to avoid buildup.”
Keep reading for a few more favorites that will extend the life of your tan (and keep you moisturized for your next one).

Jergens Natural Glow Gradual Daily Moisturizer

Jergens Natural Glow Daily Moisturizer
Jergens Natural Glow Gradual Daily Moisturizer $10.00

Keep your tan intact (without pulling at your purse strings) with Jergen’s daily moisturizer that gives you a natural allover glow over the course of a few days. The gradual formula makes it so you’re never streaky and always happy with the results.

Infinity Sun Hydrating Skin Extender

Infinity Sun Hydrating Skin Extender $40.00

Try this super-hydrating serum chock-full of antioxidants, botanicals, and DHA, designed to keep your skin soft and extend your tan for an additional two to three days.

Charlotte Tilbury Supermodel Body

Charlotte Tilbury Supermodel Body $65.00

Not only does this product add shimmer and radiance to your bod, but it also has a slimming agent. Coined “shapewear lingerie for the skin,” the potent mix of caffeine (to tighten), aloe (to soothe), and highlighting agents (to flatter) creates the illusion of longer, leaner limbs that glow—on top of an airbrush tan.

Related Stories