No one applies makeup with the hope it won't last all day. So, it's only natural we obsessively research the longest-lasting products—the ones that will stay on through work, a night out, and perhaps even that impending snow storm. Through it all, we've realized an absolute truth: For extending your wear, you’ll need a good setting product. But the question remains... which one?
You’ve probably seen the two setting mainstays: setting powder and setting spray. The one you apply really depends on your skin type and the finish you're after. “Both setting spray and setting powder are used for keeping your makeup in place,” says Kenny Screven, a beauty influencer and makeup artist. “They may sound the same, but they have a few key differences." Screven says setting powders and setting sprays are suitable for different situations. “What they do and how they are applied are completely different,” he says. How so? Let’s dissect.
Setting Powder: What You Need to Know
Keri Blair, a senior national artist at MAC Cosmetics, says setting powder is typically used on the face in places where you’d like a matte finish. “Setting powder comes in a loose, generally jet-milled powder form and requires a brush or a puff to be applied,” she says.
If You Have Oily or Combination Skin
If you have oily or combination skin, or your makeup tends to bleed throughout the day, you may prefer a powder. Screven says setting powders can be used to zap oil, often just where it's needed instead of all over. “Setting powder can help absorb the extra oil on your skin and it's perfect for holding foundation in place,” he says. “I generally like applying setting powder after I apply concealer to help keep it in place. This helps to brighten the under eye and to keep the concealer in place for a longer amount of time.”
Dino Dilio, a makeup instructor at CMU College of Makeup Art & Design says a talc or mineral-based powder, like Armani Beauty's Neo Nude Powder Foundation ($58), is best for staying powder and oil-absorbing mechanisms. Blair is a fan of powders with ingredients like “silica, mica, and cornstarch,” which “are great for creating a soft, texture-less effect on the skin that is transparent and almost undetectable.” Try MAC's Set Powder ($36) or Ilia's Soft Focus Finishing Powder ($34) for the right stuff. “Interestingly enough, baby powder continues to be a go-to as an inexpensive alternative,” Blair adds.
The Variety of Shades
Setting powders are available in tons of shades or as a translucent veil, depending on the look you want. “Colorless versions are universal for all skin tones, while tinted kinds are used to warm up or deepen a foundation,” says Dilio.
Fenty Beauty Pro Filt’r has a range of skin-tinted setting powders—including "banana powder," favored by Screven, which is a glowy shade that won’t leave you ashy or washed-out. It's been used for decades Pat McGrath Labs' Skin Fetish Sublime Perfection Powder ($55) is finely-granulated and easy to apply for a light finish over foundation, concealer, and other face makeup. Nars' Soft Velvet Loose Powder ($37) is oil-free, fragrance-free, and non-comedogenic for sensitive or acne-prone skin types.
How to Apply Setting Powder
After you’ve chosen your powder, know you can apply sparingly, or all over based on the finish you're looking for. Blair explains exactly how it's done:
- Use a soft, fluffy brush with a tapered end to ensure even (but specific) placement, like MAC's 240 Synthetic Large Tapered Blending Brush ($34).
- Swirl your brush into your powder and apply it in circular motions, paying close attention to the areas around the sides of your nose and through your T-Zone (these are areas where skin gets oilier and product can wear-away faster).
- For a full face, use large, flat powder brush like MAC's 135 Synthetic Large Flat Powder Brush ($44), or It Cosmetics' Wand Ball Powder Brush ($48) for a softer touch.
- For a bargain buy, Elf's Powder Blurring Brush ($6) is also a great for all-over coverage.
Setting Spray: What You Need to Know
A setting spray is a liquid misted onto the skin through an atomizer. While setting powder is used to absorb oil all over or just in key areas (with a more matte finish), a setting spray, according to Blair, "gives a softer effect with less visible texture."
Setting spray is used to keep your whole face of makeup in place—that includes setting powder, mascara, even lipstick. "Setting spray is applied all over the skin, not just your face makeup," Screven says. And, some offer a more dewy finish, while others keep things matte."
If You Have Dry Skin
Different setting sprays work better for various skin conditions. Humectant mists are “ideal for dry skin, as they attract and trap moisture into the skin,” Dilio says. Tatcha's Luminous Dewy Skin Mist, for instance, is formulated with 20 percent botanical oils, leaving the skin hydrated and soft. And then there's illuminating mists, which contain micro-fine light reflective particles that lend radiance and glow to the face. Cover FX has a great mattifying and illuminating spray in its range of setting products. Blair says if you have flaky skin, especially in the winter, opting for a spray might be preferable. “I find that drier skin types will often prefer a spray, as it sets makeup without adding texture or additional coverage,” she says.
If You Have Oily or Combination Skin
Heather Hughes, a makeup artist and Luminess Air’s Director of Education, likes to look for specific ingredients that tackle your skin needs. “Aloe is a soothing product to have in a setting spray, whereas witch-hazel and rose water would be two others to help control oil." Herbivore's Rose Hibiscus Spray is great for combination skin. MAC Prep + Prime Fix+ ($30), preferred by Dilio, comes in multiple formulations like soothing lavender. Colour Pop's Setting Spray ($12) extends the wear of makeup, while moisturizing and softening skin with coconut water. "Mattifying mists," Dilio adds, "are made for oily skin, and contain ingredients with properties to keep skin matte and control unwanted shine."
If You Want Long Wear
If you’re looking for the longest wear, from morning application to post-work date, multiple artists swore by Urban Decay’s All Nighter Spray ($23), formulated to hold makeup through hot, humid and cold conditions.
How to Apply Setting Spray
- It's important to hold the spray at least 14 inches from your face, as you don’t want large water droplets to mess with your makeup.
- With your eyes closed, spritz the center of your face, then again over your forehead.
- Finish with two more sprays for the sides of your face, and one last time on your chin and neck
- Once it dries, you're set to go.