Milk Makeup’s Cooling Water Under-Eye Patches Perked Me Right Up

We put the Milk Makeup Cooling Water Eye Patches to the test after receiving a complimentary sample from the brand. Keep reading for our full product review. 

Before I tried these Makeup’s Cooling Water Under Eye Patches, I was not a big fan of eye patches. Usually, I’m annoyed because they come all bunched together in a slimy bag, are so messy to apply, and slip all over your face. It almost makes the experience not worth it. These are far superior. For starters, they come individually packaged. They also have an unbelievably perfect grip and a lasting cooling sensation that makes them feel like a treat. Before I knew it I was using them at my desk during the workday, first thing in the morning, and to get ready for a night out.

Allow me to explain in my full review, below.

About My Skin: Always thirsty

I have dry skin so I’m very vigilant about using hydrating skincare on a day-to-day basis. I’m always packing on serums, paying special attention to my delicate eye and lip areas. I also use eye cream twice a day. While I don’t get bags (even on little sleep) I do get puffy from time to time. 

I wound up using these patches at least twice a week. Often to prep my skin for early morning calls, but my absolute favorite way to use them is pre-glam. It’s an idea I got from celeb makeup artist Suzie Kim. “I usually use them to plump up and hydrate the eyes for 15 to 20 minutes while doing other makeup, so that the concealer can apply flawlessly,” she explains. Spoiler alert: I had an extra snatched, awake look on both occasions. 

Ingredients: Caffeine, aloe, and more

The ingredient list is pretty straightforward. The formula includes a boost of caffeine, natural seawater, lavender, and aloe.

They’re a great pick for someone that doesn’t have a ton of time but wants a quick refresh.

The Packaging: Aesthetically pleasing and practical 

I want to reiterate how much I love the packaging of this product. Each pair comes individually stuck to a clear plastic sheet. The top felted side has a cute ‘chill out’ logo that you peel off to reveal a gel-textured, serum-infused side. The grip is just right--enough to stay in place but not too much that it hurts to rip them off. 

The Feel: Subtly cooling 

Once I placed the pads up against my bottom lash line I immediately felt an icy chill kick in. I kept the pads on a little longer than instructed because they felt so good that I didn't want to take them off. They didn’t get warm they stayed cool, a sensation that lasted even after the pads were removed. 

The Results: Noticeably bouncier 

When I was finally ready to peel them off, they came off easily. The gel had dried and my eye area was dry to the touch. Still, it was shiny and felt hydrated. One look in the mirror and my skin looked noticeably bouncier and brighter. I also saw that my makeup sat smoother, for longer, and with no caking.

The Value: Treat yourself 

A box comes with six sets for under $30. That feels slightly steep for a one-time-use product. Still, I’m into them. These are not something I would use every day, but they are a great pick-me-up once a week or whenever you want to wake up your eye area to look fresh for a certain event.  

Similar Products: You have options

Skyn Iceland Hydro Cool Firming Eye Gels ($33): Here’s another pick that has excellent staying power. These firming eye pads are formulated with a natural proprietary Icelandic complex to target fine lines and wrinkles.

Bliss Eye Got This Holographic Foil Eye Masks ($15): If you’re looking for a hydrating patch that’s worthy of your Instagram feed, this is our top pick. Rows of holographic stars will sparkle, while ingredients like peptides and hyaluronic acid aim to plump the skin.

Patchology FlashPatch Rejuvenating Eye Gels ($15): Caffeine and collagen are teamed together to address all your under-eye woes. At under $20 for 5 pairs of eye gels, it’s a good bang for your buck.