Truth: Trimming eyebrows is probably one of our greatest fears in life—after all, the only thing worse than an over-tweezed eyebrow is an over-trimmed eyebrow. Even as beauty editors, we've inflicted one too many brow-related misdemeanors over the years to even consider doing it on our own—well, until now, that is. Turns out, with the help of some expert A-list guidance, trimming our eyebrows is actually way easier than we ever thought possible. (Add it to the list of grooming-related tasks we've just been over-thinking all these years).
To get an expert-approved step-by-step explanation, we reached out to one of Hollywood's most in-demand brow artists Kelley Baker, as well as brow expert Kristie Streicher.
Meet the Expert
Learn how to groom your eyebrows with these eight simple steps.
Choose the Right Tools
As with anything beauty- or makeup-related, the tools you choose will make a big difference in the ease of trimming your brows. You'll need scissors that are small and easy to use, as well as a spoolie brush with soft bristles. Try the Kristie Streicher The Essentials Eyebrow Grooming Kit ($225)—it comes with scissors that have lightly curved blades and a pointed tip perfect for precision trimming, a spoolie brush that allows you to brush through brow hairs easily, and a pair of chic, vanity-worthy tweezers.
Fill In Brows With a Pencil
Streicher recommends filling in your brows with a pencil according to how you actually "wear" them before trimming. This helps create a visual guide and will avoid over-trimming. To do this, use short, feathery strokes to lightly shade the skin underneath your brow hair, making sure to go against the direction of hair growth to access underneath the hair. Surratt Beauty's Expressioniste Brow Pencil Refill Cartridge ($18) is Streicher's pick because it has the ease of a pencil, gives the soft natural look of a powder, and is refillable. "The precise tip and powdery formula is great for filling in sparse areas and adding fullness and definition to the brow," she says.
Next, Baker advises taking your brow scissors (both experts recommend a pair that is slightly slanted, which provides a superior angle) and trimming the long hairs that stick out above the top of your brow's hairline. Cut the hair where it starts to bend or curl, staggering the lengths for an even more natural look. "Make sure you take your time trimming your brow hairs and don't rush the process," warns Baker. "If you trim the hair too short, your brows will look like they have holes in them."
Streicher says to avoid cutting the hairs straight across or all at once. Instead, use caution to only trim the longer hairs that protrude past the brow line, cutting one at a time.
Trim More and Tweeze If Needed
If you find that the brows still look uneven, Baker suggests continuing to brush the hairs up and trimming any strays until they all align with your natural brow shape. When it comes to stray hairs, this would be the time to tweeze them. Normally, stray hairs sit beneath your brow shape. A word of caution: Be careful tweezing above the brow—you'll find very few strays there to begin with.
Always tweeze with a regular mirror versus a magnifying mirror (it could cause you to remove too many hairs). Also, tweeze in natural light so you don't go overboard.
Finish With Styling Gel
To keep brow hairs in place, Streicher says to finish with a styling gel, making sure to brush the brow hairs up and out. We're fans of R+Co Magic Wand Brow Gel ($20) for its strong hold and conditioning, flake-free formula.