Reviewed: Essie's Lady Like Nail Polish Is Delightfully Subtle

We put the Essie Lady Like Nail Polish to the test after receiving a complimentary sample from the brand. Keep reading for our full product review.

This might sound shocking to some, but I haven’t worn nail polish in a few years—maybe even longer. My decision to stop was a mix of growing frustrated with the damage it was doing to my nails and just generally not enjoying having color on my hands. I usually take a pretty pared-back approach to style and beauty, and having a swipe of olive green or powder blue just felt disconnected with my aesthetic. So, when I was assigned a review of Essie’s beloved Lady Like I was conflicted: do I break my streak or do I opt out of the review? As you can guess, I went for it. Keep reading to learn whether my experience convinced me to give nail polish another try.

About My Nails: Always bare

As mentioned above, I haven't worn nail polish in years, so it’s pretty simple on all fronts. My natural nails are strong and I use at-home tools to maintain my nail shape and cuticle beds. I also love cuticle cream.

How to Apply: One coat

Back when I was wearing nail polish more regularly, I’d always apply two coats of whatever lacquer I was applying. However, with Essie's Lady Like, one coat was enough and got the job done. Before doing so, I applied essie’s Smooth-E Base Coat, and I followed up Lady Like with the brand’s Gel-Setter Top Coat.

The Results: Subtle and neutral

Despite my nail polish nay-saying ways, I was surprised by how low-key and natural Essie's Lady Like looked. I had forgotten how a soft shade of mauve can add polish to your appearance. The color lasted well, too, so this is a great option for those who have a low-maintenance routine and want something that will pair with a range of upcoming looks without quickly chipping.

The Value: Good

For less than $10, you can’t beat the value of Essie's Lady Like nail polish. Plus, it’s the kind of timeless color you’ll want to wear at any time of year or age in life. It's no wonder that this and other Essie classics have built so much popularity among casual fans and regular nail polish users alike.

Similar Products: You've got options

J.Hannah Nail Polish in Dune: Designer Jess Hannah created a line of nail polishes for the “color-resistant” (AKA me), which makes it unsurprising that I’d suggest her lineup. A sandy nude, the Dune shade ($19) is a personal favorite.

JinSoon x Suzie Kondi Nail Polish in Piedra: This nail polish collaboration caught my eye, especially the Piedra color ($18), which is a stone-colored cream hue. The three colors in this collection were all inspired by Mexican architect Luis Barragan, bringing a joyous, modernist energy that pairs well with summer fashion and cultured conversations.

Sundays Nail Polish in No.25: This earthy rose shade ($18) has quickly become popular among fans of New York-based nail brand Sundays, thanks to its non-toxic formula and versatile neutral finish. It applies cleanly and is great for times when true red or pink seems like too much.