Reviewed: Derma E Scar Gel Is Healing My Mole-Removal Scars

We independently research, test, review, and recommend the best products—learn more about our process. If you buy something through our links, we may earn a commission.

Derma E Scar Gel

derma-e scar gel review
What We Like
  • Oil-free, won't clog pores

  • Absorbs easily

  • Doesn't soak into fabrics

  • Will last a long time and/or cover large scars easily

  • Friendly to skin and environment

What We Don't Like
  • Takes three to six months to fully work on older scars

  • Clunky shape and size

I’m only eight weeks into using Derma E Scar Gel two to three times daily, but am seeing significant progress in two different ways: On one, I see shrinkage and less reddish color, and on the other, I see better texture, though the size hasn’t changed much. 

We put the Derma E Scar Gel to the test after receiving a complimentary sample from the brand. Keep reading for our full product review.

I recently got my hands on Derma E Scar Gel, which is one of the more buzzed-about scar solutions in beauty circles. I had two lingering mole-removal scars on my face, and wanted to expedite their progress (or prevent them from stalling and parking that way altogether).

My doctor warned me that the marks may not heal cleanly. In early December, we lobbed a large one off of my right cheek, and another from the left side of my face, between the eye and ear. And four months into their ever-so-steady healing, I was starting to worry that they may in fact not heal all the way. They had gotten themselves 90 percent of the way there, but sure enough, there is evidence of the removal in their wake (still, slightly less than the growing moles that were forming, so it’s a net win regardless). While she had given me some topical creams to help them along in the first week or two, I decided I needed an extra push all these months into the rebound. Enter Derma E Scar Gel. 

The brand’s promise, on the plastic jar: “Kiss scars goodbye. This non-oily gel is proven to significantly improve scar texture, color, and overall appearance for softer, healthier-looking skin.” 

Read on for my trial run (twice- or thrice-daily applications), to see if this claim holds true. I’ll cover what makes Derma E a consumer and editorial favorite, along with my progress after four and eight weeks.

Derma E Scar Gel

Best for: All skin types, plus scars both new and old (newer ones will require less time).

Uses: A scar gel that reduces scar color, texture, and size.

Star rating: 4/5

Potential allergens: The preservative ethylhexylglycerin is the only possible flag here, though its allergen level remains low.

Hero ingredients: Vitamin B5 (panthenol), allantoin, allicin

Byrdie Clean? Yes

Price: $20

About the brand: An eco-friendly brand, Derma E was founded in the back of a small health food store in SoCal. Powered by ethos and proactive ingredients, their formulas are kind on skin, but not on blemishes, dryness, hyperpigmentation, and the likes.

About My Skin: Slow and steady but surefire

Whenever I get a blemish or wound, it typically takes my skin a while to recover—certainly longer than most people. I routinely need a few months to get rid of dark spots following cystic pimples, and previous mole removals (yes, I’ve had a few, as my skin loves a mole moment) take upward of a year to recover. But it does always get there.

The Feel: A goopy, lightweight gel

Derma E Scar Gel Texture

Adam Hurly

Imagine hair gel but without any stickiness or heft. Derma E Scar Gel goes on light, and absorbs fully if you massage it in. Sometimes I like to apply heavier amounts and let it soak for a bit; it doesn’t absorb as quickly (since I intended for it not to), but it also doesn’t feel occlusive or heavy, especially once it’s absorbed. It’s cool to the touch, too, even though I store it at room temperature.

The Ingredients: Hydrating and smoothing

  • Panthenol (vitamin B5): An anti-inflammatory humectant that draws moisture into the skin. It can correct skin inconsistencies from deep below the surface.
  • Allantoin: Super nourishing and soothing. Allantoin helps soften and separate rough/thick patches of skin.
  • Allicin: Aka onion bulb extract. Allicin is antimicrobial, antifungal, and rich in antioxidants. It helps even out skin texture.

How to Apply: Be patient

The application is pretty straightforward: Scoop a small amount of the gel into fingers and massage it into scars. If you're applying it to new scars, the company advises applying 2-3 times every day, for 8 weeks. On old scars, you'll want to be even more patient, applying twice a day for 3-6 months.

The Results: Definite progress

While I knew not to expect an overnight miracle from Derma E Scar Gel, I do notice progress in my scar healing—and that’s reassuring considering I went into this attempt after four months of slow natural healing. There was still a lot of progress to be made.

After four weeks, I can see two different types of results on my two types of scars.

First, on the left side, I can see noticeable shrinkage in the size of the scar. That was a more raised mole to begin with, but a smaller surface area was removed. 

Derma E Scar Gel Results on Adam Hurly

Adam Hurly/Design by Cristina Cianci

Then, on the right side of my cheek, I can tell that the texture has improved, though I can’t say for sure if the size of the scar has shrunk. This was a wider mole that wasn’t raised off the skin, and it had a lot of surface area. I’m relieved, though, that the texture is normalizing. (Funny, to remove a dark brown spot only to settle into a light pink one for the next year of recovery.) I'm not sure you can get a sense of the textural change in these photos, but it has definitely smoothed.

Derma E Scar Gel Results on Adam Hurly

Adam Hurly/Design by Cristina Cianci

After eight weeks, the momentum is steady, but it does seem to have stabilized a bit on the right side (which is the left photo below). I think I’m playing a really long game on these ones, and plus, with summer coming, the discoloration in that scar is bound to tan alongside with the skin. It could mean that it takes a bit longer to disappear. I do notice slightly more progress in the past month, particularly on the left side profile (which is the righthand photo below), so I remain optimistic.

Derma E Scar Gel Results on Adam Hurly

Adam Hurly/Design by Cristina Cianci

Overall, I feel promise in my recovery, because previously removed facial moles took a year or more to recover into normal-looking skin. I’ll continue using the product, along with at-home peels and exfoliating serums, as well as deeply penetrating hydrating serums. It all can work to help correct the scar from deep below the skin, and to encourage healthy, normal cellular turnover after the fact. 

The Value: Worth it

I think for $20 (or less, on Amazon and some other e-tailers), the value of Derma E Scar Gel is fairly good. That 2-oz. jar goes a long way if you’re only spot-checking a tiny scar. Or, it goes a medium way over larger scars, which is still a great value. Just remember you’re playing a long game here, so it’s not a miracle overnight cream. That might work on a fresh pimple, but not on a deep-seated scar. It’s going to take months of turnover and cellular activity to correct this, but ingredients like those found in Derma-E Scar Gel can juice up your cells for a faster and smoother end result. 

Similar Products: You have options

Differin Gel Adapalene 0.1% Acne Gel: Differin ($15) uses a gentle retinoid to reduce inflammation and unclog pores. Use this one for acne scars, or to prevent them from forming; it will help speed up cellular recovery while it minds its other tasks.

Mederma Advanced Scar Gel: A once-daily application from Mederma ($124) delivers a different formulation of the same ingredient trio, including active allantoin 0.5%. 

Final Verdict

The longer you wait, the more permanent that scar could become, and the longer it will take to heal. Combine a 2–3x daily application of Derma E Scar Gel with a regular regimen that includes resurfacing ingredients (like AHAs and BHAs), as well as hydrating and skin-brightening serums (like hyaluronic acid and vitamin C), along with a nightly retinol for expedited and fortified cellular turnover. Wear SPF during the daytime to prevent further discoloration (and to prevent more moles, for God’s sake!), and altogether you can get your scars to heal months (or a year!) faster than they otherwise might require. 


  • Product Name Scar Gel
  • Product Brand Derma E
  • Price $21.00
  • Weight 2 oz.
  • Full Ingredient List Purified Water, Panthenol (Provitamin B5), Glycerin (Vegetable Derived), Carbomer, Allium Cepa (Onion) Bulb Extract, Acetyl Glycyl Beta-Alanine, Allantoin, Polysorbate 20, Phenoxyethanol, Ethylhexylglycerin, Natural Fragrance Oils.

Related Stories