Not Even the Brightest Light Could Infiltrate These Sleep Masks

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

When you think of sleep masks, perhaps you envision a lady of leisure, lounging in bed with her Pomeranian, a sleep mask pushed up on her forehead and martini in hand. (No? Just us?) Or perhaps you think of the frequent flyers slipping one on as soon as the cabin door closes. And while yes, they’re fitting in both of those scenarios, it may also be worth making one part of your regular bedtime protocol. Popping on one of these masks can help improve the quality and quantity of your ZZZs in several different ways.

First of all, covering your eyes forces you, quite literally, to stop the incessant phone scrolling that always seems like such a great pre-bedtime activity—spoiler alert, it’s not— giving both your eyes and mind a much-needed break. Similarly, a sleep mask is choice for blocking out any kind of ambient lighting; because our brains equate darkness with sleep, this can be a game-changer for less-than-stellar sleepers. “As well as being incredibly relaxing and soothing, they force us to completely unplug from our hectic lifestyles, and can be used to conquer stress, insomnia, anxiety, fatigue, headaches and tired, dry eyes,” explains Harriet Inglis, founder of Spacemasks. 

Sold? Slip on any one of the best sleep masks below and thank us later.

Best Overall: Slip Silk Sleep Mask

Slip Silk Sleepmask

Courtesy of Nordstrom

The beloved pillowcase from this brand may get most of the attention, but the eye mask is equally worthy of some time in the spotlight. Both are made of the same hypoallergenic silk, which, unlike cotton, doesn’t absorb moisture and glides smoothly across skin and lashes without tugging. The band is made from the same silk, too, so there’s no need to stress about it snagging and creating major bedhead and knots while you snooze. Available in 11 colors and prints, coordinate your pick with your favorite PJs or bedding.

Best Budget: Alaska Bear Natural Silk Sleep Mask

You truly can’t go wrong with this affordable pick. Simple and straightforward, it’s made of 100% mulberry silk on both sides and has an easy-to-adjust band. It also comes in a wide array of 30 different colors and fun prints (options, people, options). It’s no surprise it’s one of the best-selling eye masks on Amazon, consistently pulling in rave reviews.

Best for Side Sleepers: Mavogel Cotton Sleep Eye Mask

mavogel sleep mask

Courtesy of Amazon

Not only does this completely block out light with a unique design that covers even those tiny gaps around the bridge of your nose, but it also has a winged triangle on each side. This both keeps the mask in place—even if you’re not sleeping on your back—and alleviates any pressure or discomfort when you’re sleeping on your side.

Best Cooling: Earth Therapeutics Gel Bead Sleep Mask

Earth Therapeutics Gel Bead Sleep Mask

 Courtesy of Ulta

This mask is kind of like applying cucumbers to your eyes, but better (and less messy). After a long day of staring at your computer, or whenever your eyes feel puffy and swollen, the cooling sensation can’t be beaten. Chill it in the refrigerator for an hour or pop in the freezer for five to 10 minutes; the gel beads get nice and cool, though the inner side is covered in soft fleece so the mask won’t feel too chilly against your skin.

Best Cotton: Lunya Restore Sleep Mask

Lunya Restore Sleep Mask

Courtesy of Lunya

This mask—with 54% supima cotton—is machine washable, ideal when eye cream or makeup residue gunk up the mask. We especially like that the mask is thick and padded, with a wide strap that both prevents hair creases, but also helps muffle noise, too. Bonus points for the four pretty hues.

Best Weighted: Gravity Weighted Sleep Mask

Gravity Weighted Sleep Mask

 Courtesy of Bloomingdales

Just like weighted blankets may help promote relaxation and better sleep, the same principle applies when it comes to an eye mask. This one evenly distributes about a pound of weight against relaxation pressure points, in ultra-soft, micro-plush fabric. If you thought a standard sleeping mask was relaxing, just wait until you try this one.

Best for Eye Fatigue: Morihata Binchotan Activated Charcoal Eye Mask

Morihata Binchotan Activated Charcoal Eye Mask

Courtesy of Goop

This mask is made of super soft organic cotton…with benefits. It’s infused with Japanese binchotan charcoal, which can both help ease tension and reduce puffiness around the eyes. An adjustable band helps ensure you get just the right fit.

Best Innovation: Sound Oasis Glo to Sleep Therapy Mask

Sound Oasis Glo to Sleep Therapy Mask

Courtesy of Sound Oasis

Hold this up to a light source for about 30 seconds before wearing it. Keep your eyes open once you slip it on (it doesn’t sit directly on your eyes) and stare at the soft blue lights inside the mask; a form of light therapy, it’s meant to help boost the alpha brain waves that help calm your mind and body. You can also download an accompanying sound mediation on your phone to listen to along with it.

Best Luxury: Derek Rose Finley Cashmere Eye Mask

Derek Rose Finley Cashmere Eye Mask

 Courtesy of Matches Fashion

There’s truly nothing more decadent than cashmere, particularly when you’re talking about a cashmere sleep mask. This uses Lora Piana cashmere (some of the best out there) and is gently padded for the ultimate in comfort and coziness. Jet-setters will appreciate that it comes with a silk carrying pouch, too.

Best Blackout: Mindfold Sleeping Mask

With foam padding and cut-outs inside, this mask may look a little strange, but the cut-outs let you open your eyes completely and still be in complete and total darkness. Think of it like blackout curtains, but cheaper and easier. An added boon: Because it doesn’t touch your eyes, it’s a good pick for anyone sporting lash extensions that can't get smushed.

Best Disposable: Spacemasks Self-Heating Eye Mask

Spacemasks Self-Heating Eye Mask

 Courtesy of Credo

Not only are the one-time-use masks perfectly practical (you get five in a box, making them choice to dole out at a bachelorette party or girls trip), they have the unique feature of warming up as soon as you open them. Iron powder warms up the self-heating masks as soon as you open them, almost instantly relieving tension and tired eyes. Comfortable ear loops help keep it in place.

Best Anti-Aging: Illuminage Skin Rejuvenating Eye Mask

Best with Skincare Benefits: Illuminage Skin Rejuvenating Eye Mask

 Courtesy of Skin Store

Copper is a known skin-loving mineral, with the ability to boost cell renewal and deliver some serious anti-aging benefits. Here, copper ions are infused into the fabric, so that this mask can pretty much take the place of your eye cream. Seriously, wear it nightly for brighter skin in just two weeks, and fewer lines and wrinkles in four weeks. Beauty sleep indeed.

Best Eco-Friendly: Half Asleep Ruffle Sleep Mask

Best Eco-Friendly Option: Half Asleep Ruffle Sleep Mask

 Courtesy of Half Asleep

With sustainably sourced fibers and packaging and dyed using only plant-based pigments, this mask is choice for the conscious consumer. The brand also donates a percentage of sales to organizations that help the homeless, and plants a tree for every item purchased as well. Not to mention that the ruffled edging and band are just super stinking cute.

Related Stories