Though classic red tips are great all 365 days of the year (it’s Olivia Palermo’s favorite shade, BTW), we feel the fiery hue is most justified during the warm months of summer. Wearing high-waisted cutoffs and channeling our inner Marilyn, we find ourselves addicted to variations of the shade all season long. That being said, some tints of crimson are much more flattering than others, and certain formulas gleam and glisten far longer than their stingier counterparts. To help us nail the perfect mani, our friends at Rank & Style let us in on a little secret—the best red polish according to the Internet (along with four eye-popping runners-up). Rank & Style is known for its unique algorithm, which helps the site generate epic lists featuring the best of the best for both fashion and beauty products alike. Want to know the winning shade? Keep scrolling for the big reveal!