Hands Down: These Are the Best Mascaras Maybelline Has Ever Made

Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.

For those of us with incredibly pale, blonde eyelashes, mascara is a necessity. Actually, even if you have dark lashes, odes have been written to the transformative powers of this beauty product. Mascara has the magical ability to make your eyes look whiter, wider, and more awake, all with a few swipes of a wand. And you can't talk about mascara without thinking about Maybelline. A bottle of its iconic pink and green Great Lash mascara is sold every two seconds.

In addition to Great Lash, the brand also boasts some other stellar mascaras. From formulas for intense volume to fluttery lashes to falsie-like length, the brand offers a multitude of mascaras for every beauty look.

These are the top Maybelline mascaras on the market. 

Best Overall: Maybelline New York Great Lash Mascara

Great Lash Mascara

We dare you to think of mascara more iconic. The ultimate classic has truly earned its status and staying power, racking up numerous beauty awards along the way. After 40 years, it’s still the most popular mascara in the United States. The smooth formula glides onto lashes, delivering a full look while conditioning.

Best Curling: Maybelline New York Lash Sensational Curvitude Washable Curling Mascara

Lash Sensational Curvitude Mascara

To get the maximum curl out of your lashes, a lash curler is the go-to—unless you’re using Lash Sensational Curvitude Mascara. The wow-worthy formula lets you skip that step to get the same results. The fanned, curved brush catches and stretches every eyelash to get a curvy, layered look. Each and every hair is defined.

Best Waterproof: Maybelline New York Total Temptation Waterproof Volumizing Mascara

maybelline total temptation mascara

There are plenty of things that can ruin your mascara: a rainstorm, a hot day at the beach, a tearjerker on Netflix. But no matter what brings on the tears, this mascara will stay pristine. Yet, the super waterproof mascara doesn’t skimp on style. It creates major volume while separating lashes and coating each one for extra drama. The creamy, whipped formula contains coconut extract to condition lashes, too.

Best Volumizing: Maybelline New York Volum' Express The Rocket Washable Mascara

If you’re wondering why this mascara has “rocket” in its name, our guess is it’s because it gives you lashes so voluminous that you can practically see them from outer space. This mascara delivers a whopping eight times the volume. That’s thanks to its patented brush with a tough inner core and evenly-spaced soft bristles. Plus, the formula never clumps, coating each lash from end to end.

Best Lengthening: Maybelline New York Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Washable Mascara

Maybelline Lash Stiletto Ultimate Length Mascara

You know how your stilettos make your legs look crazy long? Well, this aptly named mascara does the exact same thing for your lashes. The formula creates 70% longer lashes, leaving them with high wattage shine. The Grip & Extend Brush gets ahold of every single lash and covers it from every angle. Plus, the formula is infused with pro-vitamin B5 to smooth and nourish lashes.

Best Falsies Effect: Maybelline New York The Falsies Push Up Angel Washable Mascara

Put down the lash glue. Forget the complicated false lashes kit—this mascara delivers this same effect sans all the extra effort. The exclusive push up winged brush is the secret behind the impressive look. It sweeps lashes to the side while simultaneously lifting lashes from the roots, delivering major volume. The formula is strong enough to keep the arch in place all day.

Best Fiber: Maybelline New York Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Washable Mascara

Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara

When you want your eyelashes to make a major statement, reach for a fiber mascara. The synthetic fibers attach to the ends of the lashes to elongate them and bulk them up for volume. This version from Maybelline does just that. The Fiber Fix Brush and sealing formula team up to deliver a luxe lash look. Illegal Length Fiber Extensions Mascara can extend lashes by 4mm of fiber extensions, all without breaking or flaking.

Related Stories