Sadly, the days of pool parties and beach bumming are coming to an end. The only thing getting us through is the realization that we can once more rock our statement eyeliner without the dreaded melting and smudging. Here to help us celebrate, our friends at Rank & Style used their unique algorithm to determine which eyeliner—based on the Internet’s popular opinion—lasts the longest and keeps your gaze ferocious. Want to know the winning product? Keep scrolling for the big reveal!
#1 Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner ($25) in Black Ink
Drumroll, please… Widely acclaimed, award-winning, and much-loved, Bobbi Brown’s Long-Wear Gel Eyeliner is the most popular long-wear eyeliner on the Internet. We’re not even a little bit surprised—not only does this liner last 12 hours, but it’s waterproof and sweat resistant, too (a godsend for your GNO dance parties). Plus, it gives you just the right amount of time to perfect your flick before it dries and sets in place. No more pulling your hair out for every time you need to start over.
Keep scrolling to see some of the other eyeliners that made the top 10!
#2 Lancôme Le Stylo Waterproof Long Lasting Eyeliner ($27) in Aubergine
We love that we never need to sharpen this liner: The tip twists to ensure a crisp line every time. Transitioning to a smoky eye for happy hour? Le Stylo comes with a sponge to smudge and blend for a more dramatic look.
#3 Make Up For Ever Aqua Eyeliner ($19) in Turquoise
This creamy liner glides on silky smooth but doesn’t smudge or fade. Plus, it comes in 25 vibrant shades—an absolute must-have in your makeup bag. We’re dying to try the brighter hues for a much-needed pop of color come fall.
#4 Nars Larger Than Life Long-Wear Eyeliner ($25) in Via Appia
Designed with a retractable applicator and built-in sharpener, this sleek liner is an easy choice for when you’re running low on time.
#5 Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner ($22) in Black
The felt tip on this liner makes it super easy to use, even for makeup novices. From thin lines to bold and dramatic, it does it all!
Click over to Rank & Style to see the rest of the products on this list! Also, make sure to check out the site’s lists of the best lip stains and tints, gray nail polishes, natural body exfoliators, luminizing makeup, and products with over 1000 reviews on Amazon! Have you tried any of these award-winning liners? Which one are you obsessing over? Sound off below!
Opening image: The Beauty Look Book