Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
If there’s something practically every girl owns no matter what stage of life she's in, it’s a hair tie. You never know when you’ll need to toss your hair up in a pony or share one with a friend in need. For that reason, 90% of us sport our favorite pony-tail holders on our wrist as a staple accessory. And we all know all hair ties are not created equal. There are those that stretch too much, some that don’t stretch enough, and some that just don’t get the job done. Below, the top hair ties, scrunchies, and rubber bands to keep your hair in place no matter what the occasion.
Best Overall: Emi Jay Hair Ties
We’re sure you’ve seen the knock-off versions of these hair ties, but none of them are as good as the real thing. These hand-made ties come in every color imaginable so you can have fun with a poppy hue or buy your traditional brown and black ties. They're ranked the best overall for their ability to stretch and hold hair in place without creating awkward dents or creases. Nobody likes the ponytail bump.
You’ll likely see girls sporting these on their wrists because they are just so cute and don’t really look like a hair band. Even A-listers like Gigi Hadid, Jennifer Aniston, and Hailey Beiber are fans of the brand, so you know they perform well.
Best Budget: Scunci No Damage Hair Ties
Scunci hair ties have been around for what seems like eons. This tried and true brand knows how to make a solid hair band and keep it at a reasonable price for the consumer. The No Damage Hair Ties have a firm, long-lasting hold without the pesky metal attachment that grips on and pulls strands. We love that these retain their shape even after months of use and they seamlessly blend into most hair colors.
Best for Thick Hair: Burlybands Ultimate Hair Tie for Thick Hair
When you have a naturally thick mane, you understand the challenges of wrapping the average hair tie around your full pony to keep it in place. There are two common outcomes. Either the elastic snaps after your first loopty-loop or you can only wrap the tie around twice so your ponytail or bun falls within 5 minutes. Thankfully, Burlybands understands the struggle of putting thick hair in an updo and created these stronger-than-ever hair bands. They are seamless, larger-than-average and super strong so you can keep your ponytail or bun in place without any pulling.
Best To Prevent Breakage: Slip Silk Scrunchie Skinnies
When preventing breakage is your goal, there’s one material that is sure to help: Silk. Silk is known for it’s super slippery texture that allows hair (and skin) to glide across when moving instead of grabbing or tugging on strands. That’s why most hair gurus recommend sleeping on a silk pillowcase at night to prevent strands from breaking while you snooze. These scrunchies are created with a long-fiber mulberry silk that is super gentle on your tresses no matter how fragile or strong.
Best Anti-Slip: Invisibobble POWER The Strong Grip Hair Ring
This cord-like hair band looks scary at first glance, but it’s actually a genius invention. Its spiral shape allows it to grip onto hair (sans the pain) so hair doesn’t budge no matter how much you move, run, or jump. These stretchy hair rings are ideal for working out or playing sports.
Best Invisible: Goody SlideProof Elastics
There are some styles that require a clear elastic and that’s when these rubberband-like hair bands come in handy. While they may not be best for everyday use, these invisible scrunchies are super stretchy with a strong hold. We like these most for sealing braids and creating intricate ponytails because you won’t have to worry about them sliding out.
Our writers spent 2 hours researching the most popular hair ties on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 15 different hair ties overall, screened options from 6 different brands and manufacturers, read over 15 user reviews (both positive and negative) and tested 4 of the hair ties themselves. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.