Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
The joys of great eyebrows really can't be overstated. They frame your face and can make you look put-together, assertive, and all-around fierce. And yet, if you're like a lot of us, you might not be able to achieve a perfect brow the all-natural way.
Whether your eyebrows are recovering from years of obsessive plucking, hard to see because they're light blond, or generally sparse, the right eyebrow pencil, gel, pomade, wax, or powder can make all the difference. And for the record, even full, natural brows can benefit from a little filler. If you've never tried an eyebrow filler or are looking to upgrade your current product, we've got you covered.
Read on for the best eyebrow fillers.
Best Overall: Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer
While most makeup companies now offer eyebrow products, Anastasia Beverly Hills has been in the brow game for quite a long time—like, even before the overplucking era of the early aughts. Needless to say, we trust this OG brand and its tried-and-true products.
The Brow Definer features a triangular tip—you can use the point to draw super-fine lines, the back for medium strokes, and the side for a thicker application. Hello, convenience! This tool also has a spoolie brush on the other end for blending. Plus, it comes in an impressive 12 shades so you'll be able to find the perfect match.
Best Budget: E.l.f. Cosmetics Instant Lift Brow Pencil
Thanks to the Instant Lift Brow Pencil from e.l.f Cosmetics, you don't have to spend a lot of money to create amazing arches. This mechanical-style pencil has a fine tip, which you can use to draw in thin, hair-like lines. On the other end, there's a handy brush for blending. The result? Full, defined, natural-looking brows.
Best Pencil: Maybelline Total Temptation Eyebrow Definer Pencil
This smooth gel formula comes in four colors: deep brown, medium brown, soft brown, and blond. Using the teardrop-shaped tip, you can fill in your eyebrows with precision, no matter how sparse they are. Once you've got the right arch, flip the pencil over and use the spoolie brush to soften your lines and blend into the perfect brow.
Best Pomade: Anastasia Beverly Hills Dipbrow Pomade
This award-winning pomade has a buildable, blendable, texturizing formula that stays put all day. Using a small angled brush, just dip into the pot and create perfectly pigmented lines to fill in your brows, then blend with a spoolie. Anastasia's Dipbrow Pomade is also fast-drying and waterproof. Once you've filled your eyebrows in, you can go about your day (or night) with the confidence of flawless arches that won't smudge.
Best Powder: Benefit Cosmetics Foolproof Brow Powder
Powders can be really great for filling in brows, and this one from Benefit will not disappoint. The two-toned pigment is supposed to mimic the look of natural brows—the lighter shade goes on the thicker portion of your arch, and the darker color goes on the tail.
Using the included sponge applicator or the brush of your choice, dip into the velvety-smooth powder and start defining and filling in your eyebrows. Then blend with the included spoolie. As the cheeky name suggests, this eyebrow filler is foolproof—whether you're an expert or a novice, you'll nail exemplary arches.
Best Kit: Rimmel Brow This Way Eyebrow Sculpting Kit
This affordable kit comes with a powder, a wax, a dual-headed application brush, and a spoolie. The manufacturer recommends starting with the wax to shape your brows. Next, fill them in with the powder to set the wax and get a precise arch. The lightweight, long-wear formula lasts all day, so you won't have to redo your work come lunchtime.
Best Waterproof: Stila Cosmetics Stay All Day Waterproof Brow Color
If you're partial to waterproof mascara and eyeliner, we think you'll appreciate this brow tool. The fine felt tip allows you to draw on little faux eyebrow hairs to achieve an ideal, natural-looking arch. True to its name, this marker-like filler resists moisture and smudging. With all-day staying power, you don't have to worry about your masterpiece fading or rubbing off.
Best for Dark Hair: IMAN Cosmetics Perfect Eyebrow Pencil
If you have dark hair, this dual-sided filler is the perfect choice to help define arches and fill in brows. With darker skin tones in mind, the Blackest Brown shade is richly pigmented. You'll get plenty of color with gentle, feathery strokes. Using the attached brush, you can blend the non-greasy formula for a realistic-looking finish.
Best for Light Hair: L'Oréal Paris Brow Stylist Definer
For fair-haired folks, this filler is a great choice—It comes in six shades, three of which are blond. Choose from light blond, blond, or dark blond—or grab two and blend them together. The super-precise mechanical pencil has a crayon-like tip on one end and a spoolie brush on the other. Trace your arches, then fill in your eyebrows with light strokes, and comb upwards with the brush for a soft, natural finish.
Best Tip: Uoma Beauty Brow-Fro Baby Hair Pencil
The tip of an eyebrow product is a critical component of achieving the arches of your dreams, and UOMA Beauty Brow-Fro Baby Hair stands out from the rest. This pencil was made for precision, and the retractable design means you never have to resharpen it. You can draw in extra-thin lines that mimic real eyebrow hairs with the ultra-fine tip. Once you've got your arches just right, blend your work with the built-in spoolie to create a soft, realistic texture.
Best Wax: Glossier Boy Brow
Though Glossier hasn't been around as long as many of these other beauty brands, its Boy Brow has an almost cult-like following. It comes with a dip wand and is meant to be applied in upward brush strokes—like a tiny tube of mascara, but without any clumps. The creamy wax formula instantly thickens, shapes, and sets your brows while emphasizing a natural texture. Boy Brow comes in four colors: Black, brown, auburn, blond, and clear, the latter of which is more for shaping eyebrows rather than filling them in.
Best Gel: Benefit Cosmetics Gimme Brow+ Volumizing Eyebrow Gel
Sometimes, all you need to obtain impeccable eyebrows is the right gel, and Benefit Gimme Brow+ is up for the task. The smooth and water-resistant tinted gel clings to your natural hairs and skin, providing volume and texture without any clumps. Also, the tiny spoolie makes it easy to stay within the lines. Apply the buildable formula with upward brush strokes, and add a second layer if you want more definition.
Best Pencil/Gel Combo: Revlon Brow Fantasy by Color Stay
Revlon Brow Fantasy is the best of both worlds. The double-duty eyebrow filler features a pencil on one end and a gel on the other. Using the pencil, trace your brows, draw in tiny hairs, and fill in any sparse areas. Then flip this bad boy over to blend and set the look using the tinted gel and attached spoolie. Brow Fantasy covers all the bases in one small product, and it's affordable too.
Best Precision: Dior Diorshow Brow Styler Ultra-Fine Precision Brow Pencil
Filling in your eyebrows is all about precision, and you can't go wrong with Diorshow Brow Styler. The super-fine retractable pencil offers arguably the best hair-like results. You can count on some serious definition and enviable arches, not to mention natural-looking color. It comes in six shades: Black, dark brown, auburn, brown, chestnut, and blond. The formula is firm, yet blendable—the perfect balance for the perfect brows.