Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Let’s not forget that blue eyes are a recessive gene, so if you’re lucky enough to be blessed with baby blues, why not do everything you can to flaunt the gorgeous color? And, obviously, there’s no better way to do so than with the right eye shadow. To determine which hues are most flattering for you, think back to the color wheel that hung on the wall of your elementary school art class. Because orange is directly opposite blue, these types of warm tones (namely, oranges, bronzes, coppers, anything in that family) are the best option to truly make your eyes pop and stand-out.
But it doesn’t have to stop there! When it comes to pastel shades, consider opting for cool gray blues; pinks can accentuate redness and make you look tired. As far as jewel tones go, pass on greens and blues, which are too close to your natural eye color, in favor of rich, amethyst purple. Yet another foolproof pick is a warm champagne shade; it packs the same brightening and eye-opening effect as a beige or white, without looking to stark set against your light eyes. On the search for a blue eye-flattering shadow? The top picks below fit the bill.
Best Overall: Maybelline New York The 24KT Nudes Eye Shadow Palette
Consider this a one-stop-shop for all of your shadow needs. With a dozen different shades, there’s a wide range of colors to choose from, all of which happen to be extremely flattering on blue eyes. Mix and match any of the five shimmery gold and bronze-y metallics, or use one of the three pale beige-y tones for the perfect neutral, all-over color. A rich purple will pop on blue eyes, and there are also two dark black-brown shades ideal for lining.
Best Budget: e.l.f. Cosmetics Smudge Pot Cream Eyeshadow
For less than the price of your morning cup of coffee, you can pick up a jar of this super smooth gel formula. Dab it on with your fingertips or a brush; either way, the two shades (a deeper bronze and pink-y champagne) will bring out your blue eyes. Also nice: Because it does glide on so seamlessly, it can easily double as an eyeliner when applied with an angled liner brush. Reviewers also repeatedly point out its impressive staying power.
Best Drugstore Option: Wet n Wild Color Icon Eyeshadow Single in Mesmerized
This brand recently revamped their powder shadow formula, with a supremely silky feel that rivals that of much pricier powders we’ve tried. (The blendability and staying power have also been improved.) All of the shades pack a punch of pigment, and ringing in at just under one dollar each, you truly can afford to try them all. But you’re going to have to start somewhere, so pick up this saturated, pearlescent deep purple. Whether swiped across your entire lid or used as the base for a smokey eye, it adds instant drama to any shade of blue eyes.
Best for Mature Eyes: Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Cream Shadow in Sandy Gold
As a general rule, cream formulas are choice for more mature skin; their hydrating base looks fresh and natural, without the risk of falling flat and chalky like powders often can. This best-selling and award-winning cream shadow was recently reformulated with new polymer technology. Translation: It now adheres even better to eyelids (since slipping and sliding can be an issue on crepe-y skin), so the color stays true. It glides on easily, so you don’t have to worry about pulling or tugging on this sensitive skin, and dries down to a perfectly velvety finish that lasts up to 12 hours. While you can’t go wrong with any of the shades, this warm golden tone is especially flattering on all kinds of blue eyes.
Best Natural Formula: Jillian Dempsey Lid Tint in Peach
Made with a long list of organic ingredients, sunflower seed oil, coconut oil, and shea butter make up the extra hydrating and creamy base in this vegan formula. Not to mention that it’s super easy to apply; sheer and blendable, it’s pretty much mistake-proof, even if you haphazardly dab it on with your fingertips. (And it can be layered over powder eyeshadow, too.) There are several colors that look great on blue eyes, but this vibrant peach is one of our favorites. While it may look unnervingly bright in the pan, it goes on fairly sheer, delivering just the right amount of eye-popping warm color.
Best Gloss: Surratt Beauty Lid Lacquer in Hadaka
Breaking news: Glossy lids are in, in a big way. And while many of eye glosses can feel sticky or tacky, this lacquer packs high-sheen and buildable color, all in a totally lightweight formula. Tap it on with your fingertips for a more sheer finish, or with a sponge-tip applicator for more impact. While we’re fans of all the shades, this sunset hue is especially choice for blue eyes. It looks equally pretty dabbed on alone, or paired with some graphic black liner for a more dramatic effect.
Best Palette: Urban Decay Naked Heat
The OG Urban Decay Naked palette has now spawned many spin-off versions, none of which is more flattering on blue eyes than this one. The dozen amber-hues range from burnt oranges to warm browns, and everything in between, all gorgeous complements to cooler toned blue eyes. All of them tout the brand’s unique pigment infusion system, which makes for the velvety feel and rich color; happy customers often call attention to how pigmented the shades area. Plus, it comes with a full-size mirror, dual-sided brush, and is available in a mini version, too.
Our writers spent 6 hours researching the most popular eyeshadows for blue eyes on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 40 different eyeshadows for blue eyes overall, screened options from 45 different brands and manufacturers, read over 30 user reviews (both positive and negative) and tested 10 of the eyeshadows themselves. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.