The Best Eye Shadow Primers According to Sephora Shoppers

Updated 08/11/19
Product Disclosure

They say that the eyes are the windows to the soul. So if you've enhanced your lids with a killer cat eye or a head-turning smokey eye situation, you want to make sure it lasts from the moment it's applied to the moment you decide to wipe it off. Every good makeup application begins with the base, so while shadow stylings are an important aspect of achieving that wow factor, eye shadow primers are just as essential to the beauty look's success.

How to Choose the Right Eye Shadow Primer

When it comes to choosing the right eye shadow primer, we don't approach our assessment with the same sensibilities we might with things like lipstick—where we play with several options and switch from brand to brand depending on colors. With eye shadow primers, what we seek is long-lasting effectiveness that ensures our eyelid creations stay put no matter what the day brings. And once we find it, there's no going back.

The Best Eye Shadow Primers on the Market

To determine the best eye shadow primers the industry has to offer, we scoured Sephora for its top-rated eye primers. Below, you'll find seven picks worth putting to the test in your own eye makeup routine.

Tube of white eye shadow primer on a white background.
Bare Minerals Prime Time Eyelid Primer $19
Shop

This oil-free primer goes on sheer to extend high-pigment wear without the excess feel of layers. No wonder it has rallied in over 10,000 loves on everyone's favorite online beauty shopping destination.

Tube of blue eye shadow primer on a white background.
Too Faced Shadow Insurance $22
Shop

This ultra-lightweight formula creates a smooth and even canvas for makeup application. What's more, it combats creases and fading for up to 24 hours, which has helped to earn it over 80,000 loves from Sephora shoppers.

Eyeshadow Primer Potion - Original 0.33 oz/ 10 mL
Urban Decay Original Eyeshadow Primer Potion $24 $12
Shop

Polymer technology is implemented to fill imperfections on the skin's surface using this beige 24-hour primer, which has earned a whopping 250,000 loves on Sephora.

Tube of white eye shadow primer on a white background.
Nars Pro Prime Smudgeproof Eyeshadow Base $26
Shop

This clear primer (which has earned over 70,000 loves on Sephora) is formulated with special deep-sea and antioxidant rice extracts to keep lids hydrated and looking as if your eye shadow has just been freshly applied all day long.

Tube of Smashbox 24 Hour Photo Finish Shadow Primer on a white background.
Smashbox 24 Hour Photo Finish Shadow Primer $21
Shop

Created by the same brand behind every beauty fanatic's beloved Photo Finish Primer, this eye shadow base (which ranks in at 20,000 loves) helps adhere even the glitziest shadows to lids, promising up to 24 hours of wear.

Stay Don’t Stray 360 Degree Stay Put Eyeshadow Primer on a white background.
Benefit Cosmetics Stay Don’t Stray 360 Degree Stay Put Eyeshadow Primer $26
Shop

20,000 Sephora shoppers agree, you're going to fall head over heels for this tinted eye shadow primer. Unlike other eye primers, this formula works in a 360 degree manor, helping not only eye shadow stay put, but under-eye concealer, too.

Fenty Beauty Pro Filt'r Amplifying Eye Primer on a white background.
Fenty Beauty Pro Filt'r Amplifying Eye Primer $22
Shop

If Rihanna has taught us anything with her makeup collection (apart from the importance of shade-inclusive ranges), it's that bold color that lasts is supreme. So it's no wonder that the singer-turned-beauty mogul would create an eyeshadow primer that has the Internet collectively losing their ish. The fan-favorite formula—raking in 20,000 loves and counting—helps smooth lids for better blending and a more even eye makeup application.

Related Stories