The #1 Drugstore Eyeliner on the Internet Is…

Updated 09/08/17
Original Illustration by Ellie Benuska

There’s no doubt that a flick of eyeliner can transform an entire look. Whether it’s a subtle swipe or a thick, dramatic wing, eyeliner adds an unmistakable oomph. On the flip side, when eyeliner is less than perfect, it’s all too noticeable. Our eyeliner must be these three things at the bare minimum: pigmented, smudge-proof, and easy to apply. Otherwise, we end up with faded color, flakes, or dreaded raccoon eyes.

Finding the perfect eyeliner formula can be challenging, but the journey is well worth it for killer wings that last all day. Fortunately, this journey to eyeliner nirvana doesn’t have to cost you designer prices. Our friends at Rank & Style used their unique algorithm, which draws from data all over the Internet to determine the best fashion and beauty products on the market, to compile a list of the most popular and well-loved drugstore liners. You can rest easy knowing that these products are tried and true, with great reviews and major buzz.

Keep scrolling to find out the top five drugstore eyeliners on the internet!

Maybelline Line Stiletto
Maybelline Line Stiletto $8
Shop

This felt-tip eyeliner from Maybelline is flexible enough to provide a smooth and precise application without tugging or dragging the delicate skin around your eyes. The tube is shorter than most felt-tip eyeliners, making it perfect for beginners who need a little help holding their eyeliner steady and creating precise lines.

Essence Eyeliner Pen Waterproof
Essence Eyeliner Pen Waterproof $3
Shop

For a long-lasting option, this waterproof eyeliner from Essence won’t fade or flake throughout the day. While the slightly thicker felt tip may not give you an ultra-precise cat eye, it’s perfect for an everyday look. Not to mention this wallet-friendly pick costs less than your Starbucks order.

Exaggerate Full Colour Eye Definer
Rimmel Exaggerate Full Colour Eye Definer $5
Shop

While felt tips seem to be the trend as of late, many of us still prefer a classic eyeliner pencil. This fan-favorite from Rimmel glides on smooth and stays put all day, perfect for lining the waterline or whatever liner look you want to create. Plus, the twist-up packaging means you can skip the sharpener.

Nyx Collection Noir Liquid Black Liner
Nyx Collection Noir Liquid Black Liner $15
Shop

Beauty fiends love this liquid liner from Nyx for its ultra-thin brush that allows for a sharp, precise, and buildable application. It’s perfect for creating a sharp flick for a dramatic wing, with bold black pigment to complete the look.

almay Liquid Eyeliner
Almay Liquid Eyeliner $8 $6
Shop

Coming in at the number one spot, this eyeliner from Almay wins the gold. The flexible felt tip allows for a smooth and controlled application so you get a precise line every time. Plus, you never have to worry about the product fading or drying out in the packaging—the ultra-black liquid is kept in an “inkwell” that ensures you’re picking up fresh pigment with every application.


Did your favorite eyeliner make the cut? Head over to Rank & Style to see the rest of the products on the list.

Related Stories