There comes a certain time in your life when you start to develop a close, personal relationship with your eye cream. Your love for lipstick, blush, and foundation won’t waver, but eye cream will grow from a casual fling to something you use every day—sometimes multiple times a day—and cling to desperately in times of emotional distress (i.e., when you wake up one day and notice crow’s feet for the first time). The bright side? Because of eye cream, your tired eyes and dark circles lighten up. The downside?
So does your wallet.
With that in mind, we asked our friends at Rank & Style—a site that simplifies the shopping process by bringing you unbiased top-10 lists of the best fashion and beauty products—to compile the top-selling drugstore eye creams in the U.S. Using their unique algorithm, they’re sharing the eye creams that fly off the shelves and give stiff competition to their more expensive counterparts. Keep scrolling to see them all!