Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
While there are tons of mascara options on the market, a curling formula helps to pump up and lengthen stumpy or straight lashes. It’s the type of flutter that makes your friends think you were lucky enough to be born with amazing lashes. Here are the top curling mascaras on the market with award-worthy formulas we can’t stop swiping on.
Best Overall: Benefit Roller Lash Curling & Lifting Mascara
Remember those old-school hair curlers your mom trotted around the house wearing every morning? Well just like those hot rollers gave moms tresses major bounce, so does this top-selling formula. This mascara is relatively new to the market, launching less than five years ago, but it quickly soared to the top of the best-selling list and here’s why users can’t stop swiping it because it literally replaces your eyelash curler. The brush has flexible mini rubber hooks that grab every lash, even those hard to reach stubborn ones in the corners of your peepers. Not to mention your lashes will look so long, people might assume you’re wearing falsies.
Best Budget: L’Oreal Voluminous Original Mascara
Even if you’re a makeup minimalist, mascara is a step you don’t want to skip. But not all of us want to spend a fortune on a formula that works. Enter in this budget-friendly find that gives lashes va-va-volume. While the selling point on this pick is its ability to thicken and volumize your flutter, you’ll be quite impressed with the amount of curl your lashes get with this drugstore formula. For such a great price, it’s totally worth the buy if you’re looking for a formula that gives major curl and volume.
Best Drugstore: Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara
There are two key components to a good mascara: The formula and the brush. And this drugstore option wins in both categories. Let’s start with the brush. Maybelline experts discovered a full-lash requires mascaras to coat every single lash around your peepers. Since there are approximately 90-150 lashes on your upper lid and 70 on your lower lid, there’s great potential for a major flutter if you play your cards right. The Lash Sensational brush has 10 layers of bristles to ensure each and every lash is coated with this curl-boosting formula. Voila! A fanned-out flutter you never knew you had.
Best for Hold: Trish McEvoy Lash Curling Mascara
If your lashes naturally grow straight or turned down, a curling formula with major hold is a must. This water-resistant mascara uses a tubing formula to lift and hold lashes into place and it’s actually quite genius. If you’re not familiar with tubular mascaras, these are easy-to-wash off formulas that coat tiny tubes around lashes which locks them into place until you’re ready to remove. This type of formula is best if you live in a humid region or you’re simply looking for lashes to stay-put all-day long. Once it’s time to snooze, simply use warm water and you’ll see the tiny tubes fall off so don’t be alarmed if it doesn’t look like the typical black smudge you’re used to seeing.
Best for Length: Eyeko Black Magic Mascara
This London-based mascara brand will wow you with the extreme curl and volume it gives. With 4.5 out of 5 stars on Ulta’s website, users claim after just one use it quickly replaced their holy grail formulas. It's a clump-free formula with a curved brush that helps lift even the most stubborn lashes into place. Like the previous pick, this option has a tubing formula so you know lashes won't fall throughout the day. And the addition of keratin works to strengthen and nourish your natural lashes so you may notice lash growth over time.
Best Waterproof: Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara
If there was a ranking of the best mascaras in all time, this would be amongst the top of the list. Pros rave over its ability to add length, volume and curl to lashes without the need for touch-ups throughout the day. Not only is it the brands top-seller, but this cult-favorite was also ranked the #1 best-selling prestige mascara and for good reason. After all, if it's better than sex, you know this lash-perfector will not disappoint. As for what’s inside the bottle, it has a thick, black formula that coats lashes with film-forming polymers to lock that fanned look into place. With only one coat, you’ll have luscious, full doll-like lashes that everyone will notice (literally). Don’t be shocked when you get loads of compliments about your new flutter.
Best for Short Lashes: DiorShow Overcurl Mascara
Sometimes curling isn’t the only thing our lashes need to wow. If your natural lashes are short and stubborn, this luxury formula will stretch them to the max with its incurved brush. The formula itself is full of lash-conditioning ingredients that not only nourish lashes (fingers crossed to help them grow) but also holds the curl in place all day long. Users love how quickly the pigment dries so lashes seem locked-in-place only seconds after application. But let’s be honest, does Dior produce anything we aren’t sure to swoon over? Our sentiments exactly.
Our writers spent 1 hour researching the most popular curling mascara on the market. Before making their final recommendations, they considered 11 different mascaras overall, screened options from 9 different brands and manufacturers, read over 10 user reviews (both positive and negative), and tested 3 of the mascaras themselves. All of this research adds up to recommendations you can trust.