The Broke Girl's Guide to Buying Supplements—Because Being Healthy Ain't Cheap

Shopping for supplements can be a tricky business—are you getting the right ones? Do you really need to take all of them? Is a complex better than single nutrients taken individually? And if so, what’s the winning combination? What’s more, we haven’t even got to the price at checkout yet—after all, being super healthy is seldom the cheap option.

But if you’ve been muddling your way through the supplements aisle without a clue, or adding bottles to your basket only to abandon shop halfway through, you’ve landed in the right place. We’re about to break the whole thing down and save you cash while we’re at it. Yes, buying quality supplements on the cheap can be done. You just need to know how to go about it. Enter our expert, Lorna Driver-Davies, nutritional therapist at Wild Nutrition.

Keep scrolling for the complete guide to buying supplements on a budget—and how to know what you should really be taking.

#1. Do your research

Going on a supplement shopping spree blind to the actual nutrients you need is the fastest way to say goodbye to your cash. “The market is full of new supplements and health products coming out all the time, and it’s easy to think you need everything,” says Driver-Davies. “When I see clients in the clinic, they often have cupboards full of products, half of which they don’t need, and many overlaps—which means three products could be condensed in just using one.” So how do you know what you should be spending on? Driver-Davies has three tips.

1. Speak to a nutritional therapist or nutritionist.

“A practitioner will look at your health goals and give you a personalized plan. This means your supplements are tailored to you, and you can also skip buying nutrients that you’re better off getting straight from food.”

2. Get advice from a supplement company.

“At Wild Nutrition, for example, we have a technical advice email and telephone line where we can help customers work out what they need to take (or not). It’s also worth bearing in mind some supplements are not designed to be taken long term, so getting a professional view on a timeline is helpful, otherwise, you can end up spending money on supplements for longer than you need.”

3. Get your nutrient levels checked.

“You can do this with your doctor or privately with a nutritional therapist/nutritionist. For example, women are often low in iron. Your GP can check this by running a full blood count with iron, but do make sure you request something called ferritin—as this is a measurement of your stored iron.”

#2. Understand the key nutrients

So once you’ve got a better idea about the kinds of supplements you do or don’t need, the next thing to do is make sure you understand what each of the key nutrients do so you can better decipher labels and spot a multivitamin or nutrient complex that’ll suit you.

“A classic thing people do is buy lots of bottles of single nutrients. If they got some professional advice, however, they may find they can use a complex that contains all the nutrients required, in just one or two bottles rather than five or six,” explains Driver-Davies. Cue her guide to the key nutrients for women, and what they take care of in the body.

Zinc: Good for balancing hormones, menstrual health, regulating blood sugar, plus boosting immunity, fertility, and mood.

Iodine: This is a good one for thyroid health, which relates back to female hormones, metabolism, and energy levels.

Vitamin D: Everyone should supplement vitamin D during the winter and even into summer if there is limited sun exposure, lots of sunblock being used or if you have very dark skin.

Iron: As well as blood oxygen support, iron plays a significant role in thyroid and energy health.

Vitamin B6: Taking this will help to balance hormones, energy levels, and your mood.

Magnesium: This plays a key role in over 300 processes in the body, but women often have low levels, especially around menstruation. It’s also key for quality sleep, stress management and regulating energy levels.

#3. Know what to avoid

As with everything, there are good quality and bad quality supplements, so it’s wise to know the telltale signs of a product that’s not up to scratch. Here are Driver-Davies top four warning signs to look out for.

1. Avoid supplements that use fillers and binders. “Fillers and binders offer zero nutritional worth and are usually from synthetic substances. It’s a huge sign that the company isn’t using the best formulation techniques.”

2. Avoid supplements that use sugars or sugar syrups. Again, these aren’t going to deliver any nutritional worth.

3. Avoid supplements that use colorings/dyes. “These are often used simply to make the tablet look nicer. Especially those that say titanium dioxide.”

4. Be wary of supplements that claim to contain “natural” nutrients. “Companies often use non-natural nutrients, or mixtures of non-naturals with foods, to give the impression of a wholly natural supplement. Read the small print, and watch out for iron oxide, magnesium citrate, and zinc picolinate.”

Keep scrolling for the Byrdie edit of the best supplements that won’t break the budget.

wild nutrition Food-Grown® Iron Plus (30 capsules)
Wild Nutrition Food-Grown® Iron Plus (30 capsules) $10
Together Natural Food Source Multivitamin & Mineral (30 Tabs)
Together Natural Food Source Multivitamin & Mineral (30 Tabs) $8
Viridian High Five Multivitamin & Mineral Formula (90 Tabs)
Viridian High Five Multivitamin & Mineral Formula (90 Tabs) $12
centrum For Women (30 Tabs)
Centrum For Women (30 Tabs) $10
Vitabiotics Wellwoman 30 Capsules
Vitabiotics Wellwoman 30 Capsules $7

Related Stories