Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
Since the days of Cleopatra we’ve been lining our eyes with black pigments to try and help them stand out, but as the trend in makeup leans more towards a natural, fresh-faced finish, brown eyeliner is making a comeback. While bold black liner will always have a place—and for many, it’s their staple—brown is a good in-between hue that works across the board and is a little more approachable for the less makeup savvy.
Another perk to brown liner: There are so many different shades of brown to choose from. Black is black while brown could be cocoa, espresso, taupe, and more. The options are endless, which is why we’ve gathered all of the best ones for you to choose from.
From gel to liquid, here are the best brown eyeliners.
Best Overall: Tarteist Double Take Eyeliner in Brown
Get your liner fix with this two-in-one. With a liquid liner on one end and a gel pencil on the other, you can finally save some space in your makeup bag. Use the precise liquid tip to create graphic lines and cat eyes then use the pencil on your waterline, between lashes, or on its own for a more natural finish. Another bonus: It’s made with mineral pigments and free of parabens and phthalates to keep your eyes feeling good.
Best Budget: Wet n Wild Icon Kohl Eyeliner in Pretty in Mink
For a simple, no-frills, long-lasting eyeliner, this price can’t be beaten. The rich pigment and smooth application let you create a line however thick or thin. For more precision just sharpen it up to a point or let it get low and flat for a more lived-in look. Many reviewers even said that it lasted all day without having to reapply.
Best Drugstore: Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner in Cinnabar
This easy to use liner can be twisted up or down so you’ll always have a perfect application—no sharpener needed. The small tip is ideal for fitting in between lashes, filling in the waterline, or getting into the inner corners of the eyes. Build it up with a few layers or use a single swipe for that no-makeup makeup look—no matter how you wear it, this liner is a good find.
Read more reviews of the best drugstore eyeliners available to purchase online.
Best Pencil: Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil in Whiskey
There’s nothing worse than going to apply eyeliner and almost injuring your eye because the pencil is either too sharp or too dry and won’t budge, which is why we love this one from Urban Decay. Half of the formula is made up of moisturizing ingredients like jojoba seed oil and cottonseed oil so it’s less likely to get stuck or pull on the thin skin around your eyes. Yet even though it’s a super creamy formula, it won’t smear around after it’s set—just make sure to wait about 30 seconds before you touch it.
Check out our other reviews of the best eyeliner pencils you can buy today.
Best Gel: Marc Jacobs Beauty Highliner Gel Eye Crayon Eyeliner in Brown(Out)
If you love the look of a liquid liner but don’t want to deal with the mess, try a gel formula like this one. Like those gel pens you used in high school, this liner glides on so smoothly that you’ll want to just color in your entire lid because it’s so fun to draw with. Vitamin E and rosehip seed oil are used to create the moisturizing formula so your skin will reap some benefits while you’re wearing it too.
Take a peek at some of the other best gel eyeliners available for purchase.
Best Liquid: NYX Professional Makeup Epic Ink Liner in Brown
When you want to go bold, there’s nothing quite like a liquid liner to get you there. This one has rich pigment and a flexible brush pen to help you create the exact look you’re imagining. Just use the tip for fine lines or lay it on its side for thicker strokes. It’s also long-lasting and formulated to withstand sweat, humidity, and water—no meltdowns. We also love that the applicator is almost like a marker so you don’t have to worry about spills or dripping any excess liner.
Read more reviews of the best drugstore liquid eyeliners available online.
Best Long-Lasting: Stila Stay All Day Waterproof Liquid Eye Liner in Dark Brown
When you’re looking for your liner to carry your eyes into the wee hours of the morning or simply to just last through the workday, give this liquid liner a try. As the name implies, this liner will truly last the whole day (or night) with you thanks to the quick-dry, waterproof formula. The superfine marker tip is easy to use and won’t run or feather on the skin as you’re applying it—no mess. Just be sure you know exactly where you want to put it because once it’s applied, it stays put.
See more reviews of our favorite waterproof liquid eyeliners available for purchase.
Best for Waterline: Milk Makeup Long Wear Gel Eyeliner in Bonus
Finding a liner for your waterline can be tricky as it needs to have precision without a pointy tip and it needs to go on easy but not so easy that it will get everywhere. Plus, you don’t want it to make your eyes water more. Enter: This liner from Milk. The gel liner has a small tip that fits perfectly into the waterline and glides on smooth so there’s no tugging needed. It’s also paraben, sulfate, and fragrance-free so even sensitive eyes will be happy.
Want to take a look at some other options? See our guide to the best eyeliner for your waterline.
Best Smudge-Resistant: Make Up For Ever Aqua XL Eye Pencil in Satiny Taupe
Whether you have oily lids or you’re going to be shedding some tears, it’s important that your liner stays put and for those times, we pull out this pencil. The gel-like texture makes for easy and smooth application but once it’s on, it won’t budge or fade. Headed to the beach or pool? No problem, the waterproof formula will hold on tight so you can just keep swimming.
Take a look at the best waterproof eyeliners available online.
Best for Sensitive Eyes: Pacifica Natural Eye Pencil in Fringe
Made with shea butter, jojoba oil, and mineral colors, this liner should be safe for most people with sensitive eyes. Numerous reviewers agreed that this was one of the only eyeliners that they can use on their sensitive eyes. Another perk: It’s water-resistant and long-lasting.
Best for Cat Eyes: Kat Von D Tattoo Liner in Mad Max Brown
When you’re going to put in the time and effort to create a cat-eye, you want to know that your liner won’t let you down—this is that liner. Try it once and you’ll understand why it’s called tattoo liner as it can last through oily lids, humid summer days, and even a rainstorm. But the reason we love it most for creating a winged liner is the precision tip. The tube feels like you’re holding a pen so the application is natural and fluid—perfect for pros and novices alike. Just be sure to shake it up before using it.
Best Texture: Bobbi Brown Perfectly Defined Gel Eyeliner
This gel-based pencil features a winning combo of waxes and emollients for a creamy texture that glides onto the skin with the utmost ease. Even though the formula is soft, it still imparts intense, rich color that lasts for 12 hours without slipping and sliding.
Best Natural: Jillian Dempsey Eyeliner in Rich Brown
With a base of organic jojoba oil, organic shea butter, and marula oil, this pencil is extra creamy, making the application super smooth. Flip the pencil over to use the built-in smudger to perfect your smokey eye or to blend in your liner for a more lived-in look. You can also feel good knowing that it’s vegan and cruelty-free.