10 Brown Eyeliners Ranked, According to Sephora, Ulta, and Amazon Reviews

Finding the perfect eyeliner is akin to finding the perfect partner. You look for one longer than you'd care to, but in the end, it's all worth it. As everyone's skin texture and coloring are different, it's even more difficult to find that perfect formula to go on smoothly, stay put, and complement your skin tone. While inky, intense black is an often preferred option, we're finding ourselves on team brown more often than not these days. It's warm, romantic-looking, and more universally flattering on the skin.

"More often than not I opt for a deep dark chocolate brown eyeliner, whether it be a pencil or a liquid liner, yet I almost always team it with the blackest of mascaras," Clinique UK Colour Pro Florrie White told us. "I find it is less harsh than black eyeliner yet it still gives intensity around the lash line and draws out golden, green and blue flecks in the eyes."

To find the most beloved brown eyeliner products, we researched our most trusted sites in the way of customer reviews: Ulta, Sephora, and Amazon. Below, find the top ten favorites with reviews from real people who discovered, tried, and fell in love with the eyeliner.

Now that you have the perfect liner, check out our guide on how to apply eyeliner for your specific eye shape.