I Tried 7 Blackhead Treatments, and the Best Wasn't the Most Expensive

Updated 05/22/18

Before we get started, let's get a better understanding of what a blackhead is: Once your hair follicle becomes clogged with excess sebum and the melanin in the sebum oxidizes at the surface of the skin, it turns that wonderful black color that sticks out like a sore thumb. And as overtly obvious as they are on our noses and T-zones, they're extremely difficult to get rid of. The key? Breaking down or extracting the clog and keeping the pore clean.

Since extracting isn't always the easiest (or safest) method, finding a good product that will exfoliate out the dead skin and sebum is paramount. I've tried dozens of formulas over the years that claim to do just that—some have worked incredibly well while others ended up in the product graveyard. Below, I've rounded up seven products I've tried recently and ranked their efficacy. Stay tuned for the number one blackhead treatment!

#7

Masque Bar Luminizing Charcoal Peel Off Mask
Masque Bar Luminizing Charcoal Peel Off Mask $10
Shop

You've probably seen a ton of those viral peel-off mask videos and, if you're like me, been tempted to try them. Some online images showcase a freshly removed mask with tons of little peaks of sebum sticking up, proving their vacuum power. So in an attempt to irrigate my nose pores, I slathered on the thick black mask, waited for it to dry, and excitedly peeled back the edges. The result? Only a few bits of pus—nothing at all like the images I'd googled. They also rip off the outer layer of your skin along with the blackheads (if any), making it one of the harshest remedies you can use.

#6

GlamGlow Supermud Clearing Treatment $69
Shop

GlamGlow Supermud is what I call my "skin SOS." Whenever my complexion is looking dull and a little broken out, I'll apply the charcoal exfoliating mask, wash it off, and wake up with brighter, smoother skin every time. As far as blackhead removal, though, the results never last as long as I'd like.

#5

St. Ives Blackhead Clearing Green Tea Scrub $4
Shop

At just $4, I was desperate for this wash to be the blackhead treatment to end all treatments. Fortified with salicylic acid and antioxidants from green tea, it has the potential to break down, and, in the case of the latter, prevent the blackheads from turning black, which it actually did a great job of on the first try. The only issue was that the results didn't last long, even after repeated use.

#4

Proactiv Blackhead Dissolving Gel $26
Shop

I love Proactiv's spot blackhead treatments. I didn't have very much success with its cult-loved three-step system back in high school, but its Blemish Relief Cream and this particular blackhead gel work wonders. Salicylic acid helps to exfoliate and absorb excess oil, and each morning after using it, I notice a marked difference in the size and amount of blackheads.

#3

Detoxifying Silt Gelee Mask 2 oz/ 60 ml
Volition Detoxifying Silt Gelee $60
Shop

Truth be told, when this mask made its way to my desk, I coupled it with the other formulas I'd recently gotten, chalking it up as just another product claiming to give me the complexion of my dreams. Skeptical, I gave it a test-drive, and I couldn't believe how much of a blackhead remedy it ended up being. My pores looked tinier and the unsightly black specks on my nose were much less noticeable.

#2

Skinmiso Pore Beauty Nose Pack $22
Shop

I've raved about these "Korean Bioré strips" before, but let me be clear once again: You'll need to extract the blackheads to see results. They don't rip out the clogged pores, nor do they dissolve the sebum before your eyes. Instead, the two-step patches first lift the blackheads to better extract on your own (which I've found is best done with tissue-wrapped fingers) and finally soothe and calm inflammation. An added tube of essence helps prevent sebum from filling up in the pores thereafter. I've found them to work much better than regular pore strips because the manual extraction process is more effective (made easier by the lifting patch), and the essence is quite magical at sealing the pores off.

#1

Bioré Warming Anti-Blackhead Cleanser $7
Shop

I'm in love with this cleanser. The warming effect is so soothing, and it stimulates my pores by softening them and allowing for the salicylic acid to penetrate and do its thing. The skin-softening effect also allows me to do a little post-cleansing extraction followed by another light cleansing of the area. The results speak for themselves—my nose has never looked or stayed clearer.

A few more editor favorites:

Ole Henriksen Pore-Balance Facial Sauna Scrub
Ole Henriksen Pore-Balance Facial Sauna Scrub $28
Shop

"Similar to Lindsey love for Bioré's warming cleanser, I'm partial to Ole Henriksen's Pore-Balance Facial Sauna Scrub ($28). Doesn't it just sound steamy and detoxifying? And it delivers. It warms up as you apply to open you pores, delivers glycolic and lactic acids to lift and loosen dead skin cells, and cools with eucalyptus and peppermint to tighten. Using this scrub it a decadent spa-like experience and it gets rid of blackheads too. So, win-win." — Hallie Gould, senior editor

Angela Caglia Skincare Dream Exfoliant Mask
Angela Caglia Skincare Dream Exfoliant Mask $140
Shop

"I truly can't stop kicking myself for not using this sooner. (The 'woes' of being a beauty editor—an epic overstock of products.) I've been using it twice a week immediately after cleansing, and I notice my blackheads have significantly decreased. (I get lots of little tiny ones on the sides and tip of my nose.) The formula is incredibly lightweight and clear and, thus, fuss-free, and you only need to leave it on one to five minutes for it to work its tingly magic." — Erin Jahns, assistant editor

First Aid Beauty Facial Radiance Pads
First Aid Beauty Facial Radiance Pads $15
Shop

"First Aid Beauty's Facial Radiance Pads are my secret weapon for keeping blackheads at bay. After cleansing, I take a single pad and swipe it around my face, concentrating most of the exfoliating acid on my nose and chin, which is where I'm most prone to breaking out. I let it sit for two to three minutes while the glycolic and lactic acids dissolve pore-clogging gunk, and then I follow up with a moisturizer. After I'm done, I see a real and visible difference to the clarity and radiance of my skin. It's my go-to product, and it has been for years." — Kaitlyn McLintock, news writer

Related Stories