Our editors independently research, test, and recommend the best products; you can learn more about our review process here. We may receive commissions on purchases made from our chosen links.
How do you know when it’s time for an eye cream? If you’re asking yourself that question, the answer is probably yes. As we age, our eyes are the first area to show increased tiredness, water retention, and other surface issues, to say nothing of the fine lines and wrinkles that early sun exposure starts to make evident right on your face. So how do you keep the windows to your soul looking bright and fresh? The answer it a targeted anti-aging eye cream that adapts proven ingredients to meet the unique needs of this delicate area, supporting your skin in staying moisturized and resilient.
Best Overall: Kate Somerville Retinol Firming Eye Cream
This innovative product and it’s beautiful—but functional—applicator combine forces to deliver anti-aging power to your under eyes like nothing else. Retinol—the gold-standard anti-aging ingredient, is generally too intense to apply directly to under your eyes, but this formula uses bioretinols, natural ingredients that mimic the effect of retinol but with less sensitivity, to get the job done. Hyaluronic acid hydrates and helps smooth the appearance of skin as the unique applicator tip cools skin and massages product right where it’s needed.
Reviewers saw an immediate improvement in the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles, skin firmness and elasticity, and dryness. If you are a first time user, it can take up to eight weeks for your skin to acclimate to retinol, so go slowly and back off nightly applications if you’re feeling the burn.
Best Budget: Paula’s Choice Resist Anti-Aging Eye Gel
Packed with a powerful blend of hyaluronic acid and peptides, Paula’s Choice uses proben ingredients to alleviate the appearance of aging, revealing visibly brighter eyes.
Massage a pea-sized amount around the eye area until fully absorbed while the cooling applicator helps de-puff and soothe tired eyes.
Reviewers love the light gel formulation for daytime use, which can be hard to find in an eye cream, as many effective anti-aging ingredients are photosensitive and best applied at night, and rich cream formulations can feel heavy on the eyes.
Best Drugstore: Olay Total Effects Anti-Aging Eye Cream
Sometimes, a no-fuss approach is the best way to guarantee you’ll stay loyal to a product regimen, and this drugstore darling makes it easy to afford a routine you can stick to.
Vitamins B and E gently exfoliate the undereye area to smooth fine lines and wrinkles and reduce the appearance of dark circles. Massage it in to reduce the look of puffiness and even out your skin tone, and make sure to follow it with an allover moisturizer to keep your face hydrated.
Fans of this product appreciate that it’s the rare unscented product in their beauty arsenal, making it easy to layer on under whatever other skincare you’re using.
Best Serum: Drunk Elephant Shaba Complex Eye Serum
Reviewers love the silky texture of this eye serum, and notice a fast improvement in fine lines and wrinkles. The serum contains potent doses of black tea ferment, and copper peptides that help to firm the skin, and work with a unique combination of edelweiss stem cells and niacinamide to help diminish the appearance of fine lines and wrinkles. The powerful antioxidants in Co-Q10 help reduce the overall signs of aging while also helping to fade the appearance of age spots.
Drunk Elephant as a cult-status following so if you haven't tried one of their products yet–we suggest you start here.
Best Natural: Ren Keep Young and Beautiful Anti-Ageing Eye Cream
If you’re early into your eye cream journey, reviewers recommend this cream as the perfect place to start to get in the habit of applying a daily treatment. Ren uses natural bioactives Hexapeptide 11, Hydroxyproline, and Carthame Oil to lift and firm, replenishing moisture under the eyes and reducing both fine lines and deep wrinkles. Ceramide and plant collagen help to further fortify and moisturize skin.
Ren says it’s designed for mature skin, but if you have truly deep expression lines and wrinkles around your eyes, you may find better immediate results with more powerful anti-aging ingredients. However, given that it’s 100% plant and mineral-derived, if you have sensitive skin (as many people do around their eyes) it’s more than worth a try.
Best for Bags: Dr. Brandt Skincare needles no more® NO MORE BAGGAGE™
The legendary Dr. Brandy created this advanced eye de-puffing gel to be a quick, innovative solution for tired-looking eyes. So if you wake up one day feeling like you’ve got last night written all over your face, this is the tube to reach for. It uses Brandt’s Filmatrix technology to form an invisible, biomimetic film that tightens the appearance of the eye for a visually smoother contour. Peptides also work to restore the look of elasticity and firmness while supporting the skin and helping to reduce the look of bags and puffiness.
Upon application, what you might call a cocktail of antioxidant botanical extracts and caffeine immediately help reduce the look of puffiness and decrease the intensity of dark circles. While you’ll instantly look well-rested, it also works overtime to help restore a youthful under eye shape for a consistently improved appearance.
Best Night: Shiseido Benefiance WrinkleResist24 Intensive Eye Contour Cream
Sometimes you just need to spend a night truly treating and replenishing your skin, and this ultra-rich anti-aging eye cream uses Super Bio-Hyaluronic Acid N to help counteract wrinkles all around the eye area, including crow's feet, corner creases, under eye wrinkles, lid creases, and vertical lines. While it’s perfectly safe to use during the day, the texture is thick enough that it takes a long time to truly absorb, making it a better choice for overnight use than as the final step in a daytime skincare regimen. Reviewers love how long a little bit of product will go, and some mention using it on other sensitive areas like the neck and decolletage for intense nighttime treatment as well.