10 Waterproof Eye Pencils Because Smudgy Liner Just Won't Do

Eyeliner and I have a very complicated relationship. I wore a shocking amount during my middle school and high school years, lining my eyes in thick dark lines each morning before class. Then, I decided it just wasn't for me. My lids are super oily, and the eyeliner I applied just never seemed to stick. It all turned into a huge, smudgy mess before I even arrived where I was going. 

That is, until now. While I'm still not as much of an eyeliner advocate as I once was, I appreciate a formula that stays put for a night when I'm feeling especially saucy. Keep reading for the 10 waterproof eye pencils that work best.