I’m usually dubious of all-in-one beauty products (they tend to overpromise and under deliver), but Chella’s Highlighter Pencil ($18) in Ivory Lace is an exception. The word “highlighter” doesn’t begin to do this little pencil justice. I use it under my eyes to brighten dark circles, above my cheekbones and down the bridge of my nose to highlight, and on any surprise spots to cover and conceal. The creamy, matte finish sets it apart from other highlighters and the pencil form makes it incredibly easy to use—just draw and blend. If I was trapped on a desert island and you asked me my three beauty essentials, this sleek pencil would make the list. And if you saw the size of my makeup bag, you’d know that’s saying quite a lot.