We Swapped Beauty Products With Our International Editors—Read Our Reviews
On most days, I test out more products than I know what to do with. No, really—my desk is currently overrun with essential oils, magic balms, all-natural nail polish removers and no less than 16 (SIXTEEN!) face mists. This clutter doesn't even compare to my vanity at home, which looks like my local Sephora threw up all over it. And yet, though I literally have reserves of makeup, skincare, and hair formulas ready for trial, I still have a bad case of beauty product FOMO—especially when it comes to foreign finds that aren't available in the United States.
Can you blame me for being frustrated? The internet has made our world exceedingly smaller in so many ways. I can learn about beauty tips and secrets from far-reaching countries with a cursory Google search. I can see the products I want just by scrolling through the Instagram accounts of international beauty mavens. I can summon the most random assortment of items to my doorstep in a matter of hours, thanks to the magic of Amazon Prime, and yet—and yet—there are still some that remain out of reach. Is it really so much to ask that I get to try out Rosie Huntington-Whiteley's makeup line without the added expense of a plane ticket to London?
While we're based here in the U.S., Byrdie is an international brand—we have editorial teams and standalone sites in the UK and Australia. So earlier this summer, I made a little proposal to my beauty-savvy colleagues abroad: What if we did a massive product swap? We'd send them the American makeup, skin, and haircare products we love, and we would happily fulfill any specific requests they had for items that aren't available in their own countries; they would return the favor. Then, we'd all share our reviews on our respective sites.
Several weeks and one epic unboxing video later, my desk is more overpopulated than ever—and I have at least a dozen new beauty obsessions, from an all-natural Australian hair mask to, yes, RHW's entire makeup range. And while I sadly won't be able to restock some of these items (sniff), the silver lining is that a handful of them can be purchased online—and there's always hope that the rest will come stateside soon. (This seems to be a trend, after all.)
Watch me check out all the products for the first time below, and keep scrolling to see the reviews of my favorites.
de Mamiel Altitude Oil ($44)
In truth, this little vial couldn't have arrived at a more apt time—I was saddled with strep throat when I opened it for the first time, and this blend of essential oils is specifically crafted to clear out the sinuses. Its immunity-boosting and antiseptic capabilities make it a worthy travel companion, too—I can't wait to take it with me on an upcoming transcontinental plane ride.
Lottie London Buff & Blend Brush ($15)
Though I'm more of a Beautyblender girl myself, I also can't say no to a well-constructed brush. Sadly, save for one or two brands, affordable ones that really deliver are hard to come by. So I was definitely pleasantly surprised by the offerings in Lottie's range, which are ridiculously soft and luxurious and get the job done—without breaking the bank. (And they're available at ASOS!)
Pestle & Mortar Pure Hyaluronic Acid Serum ($69)
I've actually heard great things about Pestle & Mortar, which is available in the U.S., so it was awesome to finally get a chance to check it out. Sure enough, this hyaluronic acid formula is destined to become a regular in my preventative skincare routine. (It's the perfect match for my dermaroller.)
Gosh Rebel Eyes Seabuckthorn Mascara ($12)
I am very picky about mascara. Like, very picky. It's my first inclination to be skeptical about any new formula, so I was blown away by how much I loved this one. It's ultra volumizing without any clumping whatsoever, the addition of sea buckthorn conditions my lashes, and it's long-lasting—a must for my watery eyes.
Rosie for Autograph Starstruck Highlighter ($20)
Fact: Team Byrdie U.S. has been absolutely dying to get our hands on Rosie Huntington-Whiteley's makeup line ever since she first started teasing it on Snapchat. We're happy to report that it 100% lives up to the hype—favorites include the contour and highlighting sticks, which moisturize as they define and illuminate.
Super Facialist by Una Brennan Vitamin C+ Brighten Serum ($23)
It was love at first sniff with this orange-scented serum—and fortunately the addictive fragrance has a solid product to back it up. This serum visibly brightens and deeply moisturizes my skin every time I use it. (I love mixing it with my foundation every morning.)
Bali Body Watermelon Tanning Oil ($23)
I never thought that I'd want to smell like a watermelon Lip Smackers until I slathered this all over my body. Maybe it's the nostalgia factor, or maybe it's just the subtle glow this oil leaves behind. (I'm guessing it's a little bit of both.)
But the really cool thing about this tanning oil is the way that it harnesses the power of natural ingredients: Watermelon seeds contain antioxidants and a compound that stimulates the production of melatonin, so you're literally giving yourself a natural glow from the inside out. (Read: No risk for streaks, stained clothing, or a tangerine hue.)
Hello Hair Hydrating Mask ($15)
I've only recently started using hair masks, which is embarrassing not necessarily because I'm a beauty editor, but more so because I have ridiculously thick hair. Like, the kind of hair that draws exclamations every time I sit down in a salon chair and takes 30 minutes and a team of two people to blow-dry. Said mane was dry and lifeless for the majority of my life, until I rather belatedly stopped being lazy and started using leave-in treatments. And suddenly—hello, hair! (I see what they did there.)
This all being said, though my experience with hair masks is still relatively limited, this all-natural oil blend just earned a top-seeded position in my product rankings. I left it in for about 45 minutes (with the help of the brand's handy towel wrap) before shampooing as usual. Even while my hair was still damp, I marveled at how soft it already was. It air-dried into the moisturized, glossy waves I've always wanted but don't consistently get. Plus, the pouch packaging is very portable and cute—these masks get a lot of screen time on Instagram.
Lash + Line Superlash Mascara + Liquid Liner ($23)
While the concept is clever, I was admittedly pretty skeptical of this combo product when I got a look at that liquid liner. How could such a tiny brush possibly craft a precise cat eye? Maybe I shouldn't have been so judgmental, because if anything, I felt like I actually had more control when drawing it on. It could also be the felt-tipped brush itself, which is the perfect balance of firm and flexible. I'll definitely be keeping this one in my bag for on-the-go touch-ups.
Original & Mineral Maintain the Mane Shampoo ($31)
I'm perpetually on the hunt for hair formulas that skimp on chemicals in favor of powerful natural ingredients, and O&M has been on my list to try since it started hitting U.S. shelves. This particular formula is fortified with plant-based amino acids and antioxidants, and it also protects against sun-induced fading—a must as Indian summer transitions into fall.
Shanghai Suzy Lipstick ($15)
I knew I needed to put my prejudice against lipstick aside and give these formulas a go, and even I have to admit that I was impressed by the creamy, moisturizing formula. That's not even to mention the extensive spectrum of hues—oh, and each tube is lightly scented, too.
Sukin Renewing Body Scrub ($15)
I quit face scrubs a long time ago per the recommendation of multiple skin experts, but I still love the feeling of sloughing off dead skin on my arms and legs. Still, it's important to choose a formula that's gentle enough on my sensitive, KP-prone skin. This one is just the ticket, using a combo of walnut shells, jojoba beads, and green tea leaves for its exfoliating action.
Ultraceuticals Ultra Energising Mask ($69)
An Aussie co-worker was watching as I rabidly unwrapped my international beauty swag, and she immediately sang the praises of Ultraceuticals out when I unearthed this mask. While I do wish it contained less synthetic ingredients, it was gentle on my skin and really did wake up and illuminate my face. (I have the caffeine and high vitamin content to credit for that.)